Is a high-end barbecue worth the investment?

Geoff Meeker
Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

I’ve written about barbecues several times over the years, the last time in November 2013 when I expressed disappointment with the Nexgrill portable.

It functioned OK, but required constant watching due to flareups caused by the scant distance between cooking grid and burner.

I have owned a number of grills over the years, priced from $120 to $500, and they all developed problems within a year or so.

I got to wondering: does it really matter how much we spend on a barbecue?

Will an expensive unit last appreciably longer than a cheap one in our harsh climate?

I decided it was time to find out. Five weeks ago, I took the beef by the horns and purchased a new Napoleon Prestige 500 propane grill ($1,400 at Venture Vacuum).

Yes, that’s a lot of change. But I was sold first and foremost by the warranty, which is really quite impressive.

The stainless steel body components have a lifetime warranty (the nearest competitor offers 25 years) and the stainless steel tube burners have a 10-year warranty, plus an additional five in which the parts can be purchased for half price. According to Napoleon, their warranties meet or beat those of the competition.

Warranty worth it

I have seen two barbecue drums actually disintegrate and most have required a new burner every year, so this warranty offers substantial peace of mind.

Also, the barbecue has an infrared side burner, something I have written about previously, but have never seen in action.

As well, it didn’t hurt that the company offered a free accessories promotion at time of purchase, including a pizza stone and cutter, cast iron charcoal pan and smoker, a wooden cutting board with stainless steel bowls and a three-piece set of utensils.

On top of that, the rotisserie and motor are pre-installed as standard equipment.

Finally, the product is made in Barrie, Ont., and it’s nice to support a Canadian manufacturer.

So, what is this infrared side burner all about?

In a nutshell, the propane is fired through a ceramic plate with small holes that concentrate the flame, making for a much hotter fire while consuming less fuel.

Infrared is used mainly to sear steaks and other cuts of meat before moving them to the main burner, creating that restaurant-style taste on the outside while sealing the juices inside.

The side burner can also be used for boiling and frying, a very important detail as winter approaches and we ponder the possibility of another Dark NL (whether caused by storms, fires or errant crows). I do intend to use the barbecue year-round and in the event of a blackout it will do nicely as an outdoor kitchen.

I have used the infrared burner several times to sear steak, but there is definitely a learning curve attached to this. Most came out fine, but at least one steak was so badly burned on the outside that it was ruined.

There are three factors to consider when using infrared — cooking time, the adjustable height of the grill, and the level of gas used on the adjustable controller.

I know that the feature works and the results can be spectacular — I just need to fine-tune the process.

There is also an infrared rear rotisserie burner that puts out a lot of heat — so much that you need to use it with care.

 I almost ruined two whole chickens by setting the rear burner on high and leaving it for five minutes.

When I lifted the lid, the birds had been severely tanned. I salvaged supper by turning the burner way down and cooking more slowly but, again, there’s that learning curve.

The ignition system for the four main burners is impressive indeed. I’ve never seen anything like it.

Most self-lighting burners send out that clicking little spark when you turn the gas on.

Not this baby. It has a small pre-burner that shoots a small flame across the main burner, lighting it reliably every time — even in wind. How long it lasts is another question, but it’s something I’ll be watching closely.

Speaking of wind, this is the first barbecue I’ve seen that is impervious to it. It has a back wall so that heat doesn’t get sucked out through the hinge area.

It is vented, of course, but baffled so nicely that air can get in and smoke can escape without winds putting out the fire or sucking out the heat. In a breezy place like Newfoundland, this is a small miracle.

My first impressions of the barbecue are quite favourable. However, I have not had an opportunity to use all the features, let alone use them properly.

I have still to try the charcoal insert and smoker tray, and haven’t barbecued a whole turkey yet. And I intend to purchase some optional accessories that further enhance the grilling process. I will provide an update once I’ve come to know the Napoleon better, and will keep a close eye on its performance — and perseverance — through our brutal winters.  

Geoff Meeker is a communications

consultant with a soft spot for technology. He also writes a blog about the local media scene, which is hosted at Reach him at geoffmeeker(at)

Geographic location: Barrie, Newfoundland

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page



Recent comments

  • Brian Griffiths
    August 08, 2014 - 17:53

    I also bought the P500 RSIB with the free accessories a couple of weeks ago and other than the expected learning curve due to the heat generated by this baby, I am very happy. As for the seemingly high initial cost, I bought this Napoleon to replace my P308 that I have had for 20 years (still working!) so as far as I'm concerned, it's money well spent.

  • Mike
    August 07, 2014 - 17:51

    I have a Napoleon Prestige Pro 500RSIB I purchased last year, which cost about $2300 Canadian taxes/install in. The side burner is awesome, as you've mentioned, to sear meat to go on the main grill (or steaks that some folks want very rare) and boiling things (great for corn this time of year so that you don't have that corn smell through your house for three daya). Mine also has the ice bucket/cutting board on the right, four inside burners, infrared inside burner and dials that illuminate at night. I've cooked steaks, chicken, turkey, ribs, etc on it, and picked up the griddle to let you make brekkie on the grille too. I've also yet to try the charcoal/smoker tray, but did make pizza on it which turned out great. You can also bake (yes, you heard me, bake) on it and works out great too. The thing I love on it too is the grease tray slides easily out the back for easy cleaning, and I purchased cleaner to keep it shiny as much as I can (am in Ontario, Canada). I purchased mine at a local gas dealer (have the natural gas model) as the ones at the big box stores weren't the ones made in Barrie. Is the BBQ worth it? Does a bear crap in the woods? :-) best money spent on an awesome culinary machine that can take the worst that winter can throw at it (BBQ ed all winter on it this past winter) and in the depths of summer.. great warranty, great support from the folks at Napoleon, and Canadian made which is icing on the cake. I looked at the other high end model companies but only Napoleon had vents that aimed down (so if caught BBQing in the rain, no water gets into the unit). Worth every penny and then some.

  • angie
    August 06, 2014 - 16:13

    We purchased our Napoleon bbq 5 years ago and its been well worth ever cent we spent on it... Dont think i would ever purchase anything different again...