Man who killed Toronto cop was psychotic, forensic psychiatrist tells court
TORONTO - A man on trial for killing a Toronto police officer was psychotic when he rammed into the sergeant with a stolen snow plow and may be schizophrenic, court heard Thursday.
Richard Kachkar, 44, appears to have been suffering for several years from a "low-grade" mental illness with periodic spikes, such as in 2006 when he woke up in the middle of the night screaming that he was possessed by the devil and slapped his wife, a psychiatrist testified.
There was also a "very serious" exacerbation not long before Kachkar killed Sgt. Ryan Russell on Jan. 12, 2011, forensic psychiatrist Dr. Philip Klassen said.
"I formed the opinion that from a purely psychiatric perspective I felt that on the balance of probabilities he was not able to appreciate the nature and quality of his actions or their rightness or wrongness," Klassen said.
Kachkar's symptoms do not fit neatly into any one category, Klassen said, noting if he had to offer a diagnosis it would be either an unspecified psychotic disorder or possibly schizophrenia. Klassen added that he thought Kachkar was exaggerating his reported amnesia surrounding Russell's death.
Kachkar has pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder and his lawyers are urging the jury to find him not criminally responsible — a finding that means he had a mental disorder and couldn't appreciate what he was doing.
The judge has told the jury that there is "no doubt" Kachkar was driving the stolen plow when it hit and killed the 35-year-old officer, but what is at issue is Kachkar's mental state.
Friends have said that in the days before Russell's death Kachkar was behaving strangely, sleeping with his arms crossed like a mummy and talking about "white Jesus" and cameras being everywhere.
As he drove the stolen snow plow wildly around the streets of Toronto that morning for two hours he was yelling about the Taliban, Chinese technology, "Russian Facebook" and paramedics putting microchips in his body, his trial has heard.
Russell was killed after he got out of his cruiser to try to stop the snow plow, which was driving into oncoming traffic and crashing into other vehicles.
The best explanation for Kachkar's behaviour that day is that he was becoming progressively more paranoid, making choices not founded in reality, but based on his paranoid psychotic world view, Klassen said.
Corrections records show that at times in jail he had symptoms — such as hearing voices — and the rest of the time his behaviour was unremarkable, Klassen said.
His symptoms seem to improve on their own, without antipsychotic medication, which is unusual, he said.
Klassen, who was asked by the Crown to examine Kachkar but was called as a defence witness, spent more than 10 hours interviewing Kachkar, spoke to his estranged wife and daughter and looked over voluminous other materials in preparing his report.
He described Kachkar as a man whose "grandiose" business schemes involved at various times the Kardashian sisters, a bakery for dogs and a Russian submarine. Among Kachkar's possessions were pages of hand-written notes of plans for architecture, banking, commerce and information technology business ventures with the tabloid-fodder Kardashian family.
Klassen said when he asked Kachkar about the notes he "normalized" the plans, talking about their shared Armenian heritage.
Kachkar was described by family as intrusive, controlling, argumentative and demanding, and police were called on a few occasions for incidents of pushing and shoving, Klassen said.
Kachkar and his wife separated around 2006, when she reported to social workers that she was worried about him because she thought he was mentally ill, Klassen said.