Cheng, David navigate the greats

Jean Snook
Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

Newfoundland Symphony Orchestra kicks off new season

On Friday’s Opening Night, the Newfoundland Symphony Orchestra (NSO) had students from three schools present in the audience.

Newfoundland Symphony Orchestra (NSO) conductor Marc David and pianist Angela Cheng helped make the opening night of the NSO’s season a huge success on Friday night. — Photo by Jean Snook/Special to The Telegram

That is an excellent strategy, and one that is sure to leave lifelong impressions. Ideally, the students would be told something factual about the music, with short examples, e.g. the third movement of the piano concerto is a Rondo, you will hear this theme three times. And ideally, someone knowledgeable about the composers would speak of them with respect.

If a sponsor is going to indulge in prurient speculation, he should probably not be handed the microphone.

The first piece was by a composer with a Newfoundland connection: Kati Agócs (born in 1975) began her teaching career in Memorial University’s School of Music in 2006-2008. She is now on faculty at the New England Conservatory in Boston, but maintains a permanent work studio here in Flatrock.

Her short, four-minute piece, entitled “Shenanigan,” was first performed in 2011. It begins with loud dissonance, but soon works in a simple tune based on the interval of a fourth that captures the essence of Atlantic Canada’s reels.

Driven along by the strings, it is a showpiece for solo flute and for percussion: drums, wood blocks, tambourines, cymbals, and maracas. “Shenanigan” whirls with the energy, struggle, and humour of the people of our region.

The NSO has an expanded string section this year, with more violins and cellos, and this made for a wonderfully rich orchestral sound in their performance of Robert Schumann’s Symphony No. 4, Op. 120, in D minor. Schumann (1810-1856) was a brilliant man of mercurial temperament, a writer as well as a composer, who presented opposing viewpoints under the pen names Eusebius and Florestan.

Much of his work, as was later discovered by British cryptographer Eric Sams, is cleverly encoded, containing motifs for his wife’s name Clara, for his own name and for the names of others.

Richard Wigmore’s excellent liner notes to the 1973 recording of this symphony by the Staatskapelle Dresden, conducted by Wolfgang Sawallisch, call this symphony “intense and unsettling,” and explain that it has “a symphonic design of revolutionary originality, in which virtually all the material grows from the motifs announced in the slow introduction.”

 The NSO’s four French horns made a glorious sound, as did the three trombones and two trumpets, and there was more solo work for principal flute Grace Dunsmore, whose playing consistently meets a high standard.

Marc David conducted the Schumann symphony by heart.

The pièce de résistance, Johannes Brahms’ Piano Concerto No. 1, Op. 15, in D minor, with guest soloist Angela Cheng, was the entire second part of the program.

It was a superb performance. To understand just how good it was, one needs to have done some comparative listening.

Performances and recordings by other soloists and orchestras reveal this as an exceedingly difficult concerto to hold together. It can sag and bag, slip and slide.

Strange things have been tried with it. Some recordings are barely recognizable as the music of Brahms, who lived from 1833 to 1897.

To me, the recording that remains unexcelled is the Deutsche Grammophon 1972 recording of Eugen Jochum conducting the Berlin Philharmonic with Emil Gilels at the piano, a recording that Jochum, at the end of his career, considered his best.

Yet the Friday night performance, with David conducting the NSO and Cheng at the piano, trumped the Jochum/Gilels recording.

Jochum makes the orchestra’s opening measures sound like the theme for a horror movie; one has to ask why. David, by way of contrast, remained true to the composer’s musical direction, “Maestoso,” with majesty or dignity, thereby allowing the piano’s beautiful expansive theme to enter as part of the ongoing discussion rather than as a dissenting voice.

I have seldom seen a soloist so well prepared, so integrated into a concerto as Cheng. She knew all the parts, where her lead-in was coming from, and to which players she was passing it on. It was charming to see her nod graciously at the first desk first violins, or incline her head back to the horns.

With very sparing use of the pedal, Cheng made every note sing out to the back of the hall. Her website from Oberlin College states that “Angela Cheng is a Steinway Artist.” Moreover, she made the Brahms Piano Concerto No. 1 look easy, as she effortlessly and accurately played chordal passages at high speed.

With no extraneous motion, she always managed to be poised directly over the required section of the keyboard.

Both Cheng and the orchestra, under David’s direction, gave great definition to the work, shaping each phrase, lending it colour, taking their time with the cadences.

After the majestic first movement, David and Cheng again set exactly the right mood for the slow second movement, marked Adagio.

There was, however, an additional marking in the manuscript. According to the Groves Dictionary of Music and Musicians, Brahms wrote “Benedictus qui venit in nomine Domini” under the opening melody: Blessed is he who enters in the name of the Lord.

This refers back to E.T.A. Hoffmann’s unfinished novel “Lebensansichten des Kater Murr nebst fragmentarischer Biographie des Kapellmeisters Johannes Kreisler in zufälligen Makulaturblättern” (1819 and 1821) in which the words Brahms quotes are inscribed over the entrance to the monastery where the musician Kreisler finds peace.

The audience found peace in Friday evening’s performance of the Adagio. Tranquility pervaded the hall. And congratulations are in order to the horns in D for their smooth playing.

This is a long concerto. By the end of the second movement, Cheng had already been playing for more than 35 minutes. Yet she launched into the final movement, the Rondo, at a speed faster than most pianists take it, showing irrepressible vigor and enthusiasm, bouncing up and down on the piano bench, having her fun with the music.

The orchestra was with her all the way, and negotiated the perilous accelerando at the end with precision and passion.

The Arts and Culture Centre is now scent-free, as it should be, but I did feel something was missing at the end. Allow me to figuratively present Angela Cheng and the Newfoundland Symphony Orchestra with a magnificent bouquet of flowers.

Organizations: Oberlin College, Newfoundland Symphony Orchestra, School of Music New England Conservatory

Geographic location: Newfoundland, Boston, Flatrock Atlantic Canada

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page

Comments

Comments

Recent comments

  • Peter Jackson
    October 01, 2013 - 09:12

    Some clarification: First, the author here is Jean Snook. She has been our music critic for some time. Her name was inadvertently omitted from the online article. Second, I did not say the NSO is the best orchestra in Canada. I said it was *one* of the best, which, given its semi-professional capacity, I believe is true. Third, I regret that a few people felt my remarks were inappropriate or "fell flat." The people who approached me afterwards were not of that opinion. Finally, I'm glad readers feel inclined to question the quality of a review or a performance. It's the sign of a healthy concert-going community. As a former music critic myself, however, I realize how hard it is to be brutally honest in such a small town. I think Jean has managed to navigate the need for both truthfulness and encouragement quite admirably.

  • Maggy Carter
    October 01, 2013 - 00:49

    I must admit that I am, at once, perplexed, amused and bored by this article. It helps perhaps in a way that I don't know who wrote it - but I assume it was someone associated with the NSO. As for being perplexed, I refer principally to the second paragraph ..."If a sponsor is going to indulge in prurient speculation, he should probably not be handed the microphone." For those not in attendance (and perhaps even for those who were), this is ostensibly a cryptic reference to the on-stage monologue from Peter Jackson - representing the Telegram which sponsored the event. Peter delivered an admittedly bizarre historical aside on the love triangle involving Johannes Brahms, Clara Shumann and Robert Shumann. The author obviously found these comments a bit risque - given particularly the presence of a large number of school children. I'm not sure the kids would have understood or cared much about Jackson's comments. That said, they did fall flat and really added nothing to the performance. But if we're to be fair, the same might be said of this article. It borders on the pedantic – typical, I think, of the pretentiousness which pervades this segment of the music industry as a whole. There are other perplexing things about this column - among them the penultimate sentence ...."The Arts and Culture Centre is now scent-free, as it should be, but I did feel something was missing at the end". For this alone, the author should be forced to pay a special syntax. But ignoring the oddly positioned 'scent-free' advisory for a moment, I do agree that 'something was missing at the end' - the end of the concerto and the end of the article both. That isn't in any way to be dismissive of the NSO or pianist Angela Cheng. The first is a very competent organization - though perhaps not, as Peter asserted, the best orchestra in Canada (nor would I expect it to be). The latter is a very talented performer and yet I thought her rendition of the first movement rather lacklustre. (Perhaps Brahms should have thrown it away with his other failed first attempts.) While I appreciate that music is very much in the ear of the beholder, this performance was not one of the better I have attended.