Focus shifts to finding a lawyer

Rosie Mullaley
Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

Judge wants to stick to February trial date

Sandwiched between two sheriff’s officers, Leo Crockwell waits for proceedings to start at Newfoundland Supreme Court in St. John’s Thursday. Crockwell’s brother, Bill Crockwell, is shown sitting behind him. — Photo by Rosie Gillingham/The Telegram

One way or another, a St. John’s judge is determined to have Leo Crockwell’s trial go ahead as scheduled.

In Newfoundland Supreme Court in St. John’s Thursday, Justice Richard LeBlanc made sure everyone agreed, especially Crock­well.

“I’m not prepared to adjourn your trial,” LeBlanc said.

“If there’s any way possible, your trial is going ahead.”

Crockwell has been in custody since December 2010, when he barricaded himself inside his mother’s Bay Bulls home with firearms. The 56-year-old was arrested following a weeklong standoff with police.

He faces several charges for allegedly shooting at police during the incident. Charges of attempted murder were withdrawn earlier this year by the Crown.

Crockwell, who was denied bail, had been represented by St. John’s defence lawyer Rosellen Sullivan, who had filed an appli­cation to halt the case against him.

But he fired her two months ago and has represented himself in court since then.

Crockwell’s apparent lack of effort to find a new lawyer has concerned the judge, who wants to ensure the new lawyer has enough time to prepare for Crockwell’s Feb. 2 jury trial.

When the case was called last week, LeBlanc issued a stern warning to Crockwell to get a lawyer.

When Crockwell came to court Thursday again unrepresented, LeBlanc asked Crockwell his plans.

“Do you want a lawyer?” the judge asked.

“Yes sir,” Crockwell replied. “But I want to be able to pick him, too.”

Crockwell then went on a rant about having paid his former lawyer $32,000, which he hopes to get back to pay a new lawyer.

“It’s unreasonable to pay all those costs twice,” Crockwell said.

But LeBlanc said Crockwell’s issue with his former counsel is not “a live issue” and that if wanted to address it to contact the Law Society of Newfoundland and Labrador.

“This is a criminal indictment …,” LeBlanc said.

“I’m not saying to forget what went on between you and your lawyer,” the judge said.

“But that is, as far as I’m concerned, irrelevant for what’s going on here now.”

When Crockwell again insisted he needed his money back to hire a new lawyer, the judge took matters into his own hands and presented Crockwell with options.

At the judge’s request, Legal Aid Commission representative John Duggan was in the courtroom to offer Crockwell assistance. Duggan told the judge that if Crockwell qualifies financially, the commission would be more than willing to represent him.

Duggan said he would speak to Crockwell after proceedings and start the process immediately.

If Crockwell doesn’t qualify for legal aid, LeBlanc said the court can either appoint a lawyer for him or appoint an amicus curiae — a friend of the court, or impartial adviser.

“We need to do this now because we are a short time away from your trial and some big decisions have to be made,” LeBlanc said.

When asked her opinion, Crown prosecutor Elizabeth Ivany reiterated the need to get moving on the case.

The judge then made an unusual move and asked Crockwell’s brother, Bill Crockwell, his opinion.

“Right now, the choice is for Leo,” said Bill Crockwell, who stood up from the back of the small courtroom.

“Do you have any concerns about your brother’s ability to make the right decisions?” LeBlanc asked.

“That’s a pretty heavy question,” Bill Crockwell replied. “It seems you’re implying he may not have the ability to do that.”

“Well, it’s crossed my mind,” the judge admitted.

Bill Crockwell answered by saying he didn’t know his brother’s thought processes, but believes having a lawyer would be in his brother’s best interest.

The judge adjourned the case until this afternoon, at which time he said a better determination can be made as to how the case will proceed.

Meanwhile, LeBlanc also raised concerns about the publicity the case is getting in the media. Since Crockwell has elected a jury trial, the judge worried about the potential impact on future jury members.

He said he may impose a publication ban at some point.

He opted not to ban Thursday’s proceedings, but added, “That’s not to say I won’t in the future.”

Twitter: @TelyCourt

Organizations: Legal Aid Commission

Geographic location: Bay Bulls, Newfoundland and Labrador

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page



Recent comments

  • Double Time Now
    December 10, 2011 - 05:57

    He is smart! Time awaiting trail (remand) is considered double time. So, if he if found guilty he does less time by doing more time with having all the delays now. So, two years awaiting a sentence equates to four years served. If he gets say, 20 years he only has to do 16. Now, since you only do 2/3 of your time anwyway he would be in jail only 11 years. (My math might not be the best, but you get the point.) Crockwell is not a dumby.

  • John G Armstrong
    December 09, 2011 - 15:24

    I have familiarity with the courts stemming from vocation. It is a BIG (NO-NO) to do anything that " brings the justice system into disrepute." It seems to me that just about everyone connected to this case is bringing the justice system into grave disrepute.

  • GetOverYourselves
    December 09, 2011 - 14:02

    I can't believe the comments I'm reading here. Crockwell is just doing his best to act like a victim when he's anything but. He's doing his best to make a mockery of the court. He's had every opportunity to have a lawyer, had one, fired her, now a public defender's not good enough for him. He should have spent that $32000 on restoring his mother's house. It's his own fault he's in this position, no one else's, including the RCMP. He should never have holed up in the house to begin with. He needs to take responsibility.

  • KJF
    December 09, 2011 - 10:15

    There seems to be something missing here. Mr. Crockwell needs help not Court proceeding and punishment. The Judge obviously has some concerns, why don't he do the right thing and stay the proceedings. What happened here was mainly the fault of the police not Mr. Crockwell. If the police knew what they were doing during this incident I believe Mr. Crockwell would not be facing these serious charges. The Judge now has the opportunity to correct an injustice and place the blame where it belongs.

  • Anon
    December 09, 2011 - 09:25

    Can the legal system in this Province get any more ridiculous?

  • Brian
    December 09, 2011 - 08:33

    They dropped the attempted murder charges!!!! Being charged with shooting at police. The man has spent the last year in jail. now they want to tie up the courts with a full trial!!! Anyone can see there are other issues at play here,. This is still ongoing as he made the RCMP look like asses. Stay the charges and get the man the help he needs.

  • Jeremiah
    December 09, 2011 - 07:16

    What is happening here is shameful! Mr. Crockwell obviousally needs help with mental health issues and is being punished instead by a vindictive justice system. I wonder is it because he made the RCMP look so bad?