MP hosts fishery discussion at public meeting
- Top of the page
- - February 23, 2012 at 13:46:22
First of all let me ask how many fishermen could make it to the Battery Hotel in the east end of St John's. A few yes but not the many that would show up if this were held in areas truly affected by the fishery. This idea is well commended and a good idea but somehow I feel it's all for not because you will never ever get the politicians, the fishermen, their unions and the producers to agree on ANYTHING. You can say what you like there is and have always been to much distrust between all parties. They are devided by years of mistrust, greed and selfishness. I had been around the fishery in one form or another since I was a child. I have seen it from all sides. To this day I can safely say I have not seen or heard of one instance of corporation. Everyone wants and no one wants to give. The foreigners raped the Grand Banks and other grounds for centureis. We brought in the 200 mile Limit and we began to rape it ourselves. All the while the Federal government kept handing large quota's to the still fishing Foreigners. We wanted every more and the politicians gave it to us. We are all to blame and until we realize that and come together we will forever be doomed to failure. Have what politicial will you like to change this boondoggle we call a fishery, in the end it all boils down to the grass roots and what they are willing to do. Are fishermen willing to take less? Are the unions willing to take less? Are producers willing to take less? I say no because the ever present greed and selfisheness will scuttle any plan. It's all been tried and there will never be a fix to satisfy everyone. Have what meetings you like. These parties will never agree. Just like whats happening today with the war between OCI and the unions. As far as I'm concerned neither side in this battle wins and they keep doing the same thing over and over. It's 20 or 30 years ago again. I say let the fishery sink until all these parties realize that to refloat it they will all have to corporate and give in. You would think we would have learned from 100 years of mistakes. No we keep bashing our heads against the same wall.
- Cyril Rogers
- - February 23, 2012 at 12:51:59
PAUL...your comments about Mr. Morgan and Mr. Etchegarry, while probably correct about their PAST association with the fishery, does not do anything to address the PRESENT. All of us have made mistakes or held different viewpoints at some time or another but, with the benefit of hindsight, can see other options as we grow older. These two men are now fighting to reclaim what is left of our fishery....... what good does it do to put them down? We can't change what governments in this province or in Ottawa did....we can only go forward! The lack of unity among fishermen is similar to the lack of unity among our people when they reach back to criticize those who, in their opinion, didn't do things properly in the past. If the fishery is to stand a chance we must unite and that means ALL of us need to embrace former foes and rally to the cause. If a person is unable to get beyond the past, they contribute nothing to the needed solutions by simply reminding others of past sins. We need to learn from the past but we cannot use it as an excuse to do nothing or bash others. This resource is in a dire condition and will simply fade away unless we rally around it as a people.
- p earle
- - February 23, 2012 at 09:39:10
Sorry I couldn't make the meeting but I am very pleased with the summary of the results as written in this article. (1) The problems of the past should be understood for the reason of how they affect what’s going on today. (2) Ottawa controls what happens to our fishery and they have been ingrained with a fisheries attitude of complacency, and 'give away'', as that was the attitude NL gave at the terms of agreement in 49, and it has continued for 62 years to present. We to fished accordingly with the same reckless attitude without respect for the resource, and each other, and our local governments went along for the ride allowing anything to happen! What we have done, AND ARE STILL DOING TODAY, is no better then what the foreign fleets have done...take whatever you can get of the little that’s left before it’s all gone and it is going, still, right now, today, before our eyes!!. (3) The only way to do anything about this tragedy is to have our local government speak up to Ottawa to protect and preserve the stocks by having them change the federal polices. To do that all sectors in the fishery, communities, fishers (all), plant workers, coastal peoples, FFAW, processors large and small have to be on side , in unity with the premier. With out that .... there is nothing for us in future. All shore Plants will close, inshore fishers will be but a memory and what fish there is caught on the coast will be done by FFT, by foreign and local companies, for the benefit of foreign jobs, trade and profits. All for the elite who have been given the quotas, whom ever they should be no matter where they live, by the greased hands of the federal government and it’s bureaucrats! P earle
- - February 23, 2012 at 08:40:06
Unless Ottawa comes onside there will be no recovery for the fishery. Check out the link below to get a good idea of how they have been mismanaging the fishery. Gus Etchegary and others like him are right to point fingers at Ottawa even if they have made their own mistakes, because they continue to mismanage the fishery. With much less fishermen left and the cod stocks recovered, the EI situation wouldn't be such a problem. http://www.thetelegram.com/News/Local/2012-02-02/article-2884281/Report-says-science-not-minister-should-rule-Canadas-fisheries/1
- - February 23, 2012 at 07:56:15
Funny to see Gus Etchegary & Jim Morgan in attendance. They seem to have all the answers now but were part of the problem back in the day when something could have really been done. Gus was head over one of the largest fishing companies back years ago when they were using screens in their nets. Just talk to some fishermen around the province and they will tell you abt Gus. And Jim Morgan was fisheries minister back in the 80's when changes should have started in the fishery. Too many plants opened at the time, and on into the 90's. Guess he was too busy getting re elected too. So for both Gus and Jim...take a look in the mirror before you place the fishery blames on other people. I respect Ryan Cleary for at least bringing the problems to a forefront. Its a tough topic with no easy fix.
- Political watcher
- - February 23, 2012 at 07:41:58
There will be peace in the Middle East before there is any harmony in our fishery. One key factor is that the same union is trying to represent everybody and at times pitts one against the other. Sure we heard last week where the Union was ready to sell out one plant at the expense of another. I have no faith in the FFAW, all they are concrned about is collecting dues and keeping things hostile. The last thing they want is harmony; afterall, if all sides start to get along they will no ,longer be required.