Workers say pay increase will avoid skilled labour pinch

Ashley
Ashley Fitzpatrick
Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

Eastern Health tradespeople held a rally Wednesday at the Health Sciences Centre in St. John’s to bring attention to what they see as a wage gap between them and similar workers in the private sector. — Photo by Joe Gibbons/The Telegram

Jeffrey McCormack, a journeyman-level plumber working with Eastern Health for about three years, told The Telegram Wednesday he worked two jobs for a time just to make sure he was bringing in enough to support his family.

He was not the only journeyman-level tradesperson at the regional health authority to take a second job, according to comments made at a Wednesday rally.

The rally was held by tradespeople — members of the Newfoundland and Labrador Association of Public and Private Employees — working in the health care system.

They gathered outside the Health Sciences Centre in St. John’s, calling for the provincial government to increase their wages.

When asked why he has bothered to continue at his job with Eastern Health — when he could theoretically make a much higher wage at a non-union job in private industry or as a unionized worker on a large construction project — McCormack responded, “That’s a good question.”

He told The Telegram he has looked at other employment opportunities, here and elsewhere, and will likely move on if the latest call for better wages goes unanswered.

“When I go, my knowledge of not only my plumbing skills but my skills on what’s in the hospital, of the health care system, goes with me,” he said.

About 50 tradespeople — electricians, painters, plumbers — took their lunch breaks to rally alongside McCormack.

The workers said they were highlighting a growing disparity between public- and private-sector pay. For them it was specifically the disparity between tradespeople working inside Eastern Health and those working outside jobs.

They said the wage gap is causing problems with recruitment and retention inside the provincial health care system.

It amounts to one more issue in the growing list of items to be considered under the umbrella of skilled trades in Newfoundland and Labrador.

With the wail of an ambulance siren passing in the background, journeyman carpenter Mark Rice said the skilled trades workers with Eastern Health are now, on average, $8 to $12 per hour behind the pay level of tradespeople in private industry, depending on the trade.

“We’re behind the scenes in there. Nobody sees what we do. We keep all the ORs going. We keep all the sterilizers working, we keep all the T-Bar ceilings in place,” he said.

By not raising wages for the workers, he said the province is failing to recognize the labour injury to come — as the older workforce currently dominating jobs at provincial hospitals move into retirement.

“The average age back seven or eight years ago was 54. I think now it’s around 57 or 58 years old,” he said.

“What’s going to happen when all these people retire in one to three years time? We won’t have anybody left to take over when we leave.”

Rice said the issues of wages and recruitment have been before government for 12 years now, so he does not see the Dunderdale administration’s newly announced commitment to financial belt-tightening as an excuse not to address what has been raised.

Electrical foreman Keith Moore said an electrician working at the Health Sciences Centre will make about $23.50 an hour, while the wage “just across the street” at Memorial University of Newfoundland is about $33.

“We work with each other. We do power tests together. Do you think that’s right?”

Journeyman carpenter Tim Ford said there is a difference of more than $15,000 to $25,000 in annual pay from health care trades to private industry jobs.

“If you took my job right now with my years’ experience, which is close to 19, and put me down in the middle of Memorial University, right now I’d be top of my scale. I’d be making $60,000 a year. Right now, I’m barely scraping $43,000,” he said. “It has to be cured.”

Ford said he has been part of the fight for wage parity since at least 1999.

As he spoke with The Telegram at the latest rally, the shouting started up: “What do we want?” and “When do we want it?”

It was Rice who then hopped on the megaphone, facing the crowd of tradesmen. He was followed by NAPE’s Carol Furlong.

Furlong said she sees a “crisis” for tradespeople working with government, particularly as provincial megaprojects come online over the next few years, pulling skilled workers away. If something is not done, she said, “we are going to find ourselves with a major problem down the road.”

The NDP MHA for St. John’s North, Dale Kirby was the only MHA to attend the event. Kirby is the NDP’s critic on Advanced Education and Skills and Labour.

He said the labour shortage being noted in some, not all, trades is one issue for the province. The issue of the health care system losing skilled workers to high wages elsewhere is another.

“I think the workers here are making a good argument,” he said, encouraging the province and Eastern Health to find a way to “get out ahead of” anticipated worker losses.

 

afitzpatrick@thetelegram.com

Organizations: Health Sciences Centre, Newfoundland and Labrador Association of Public and Private Employees, Memorial University of Newfoundland NDP

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page

Comments

Comments

Recent comments

  • Can't have it both ways
    March 15, 2012 - 11:48

    If the government employed tradespeople want to be treated like the private sector then give them what they want. Pay them more more when times are good and less when times are bad. Yes, they can have more in wages but they have to give up their pensions and job security. The fact that they haven't jumped over to the private sector is proof that they know there is more to think about than just wages.

  • harold
    March 15, 2012 - 11:42

    question to hummm. all underpayed compared to whom? im all for paying people a decent wage. as a public sector worker your Full wage and benefit package should be made known to all tax payers after all we pay your salery. tom made valid points and so did Dave.

  • Teacher
    March 15, 2012 - 10:23

    To Humm, you really should return to school at the elementary level and brush up on your language skills. There are in excess of twenty English Language and grammatical errors in your rant.

  • Duffy
    March 15, 2012 - 09:54

    GREED!!!! If you don't like working for the government with benefits galore than go with a private company for $15.00 an hour and no benefits. The Public does not support you - be assured. In any event the real issue is with your Union that considers you not worth what the MUN guys are worth - they represented you and you pay them.........smart. Go back to work or leave!

    • Phantom
      April 11, 2013 - 14:17

      As a licenced Plumber working in the ontario health care system i can tell you that my 600 dollars a week is not enough. 75,000 a year would not be out of line for a skilled and licenced journeyperson with 10+ years of experience.

  • Humm
    March 15, 2012 - 08:50

    Well Tom Ya Don't work with Health Care so you really dont know, they are all under payed ever department worker and if someone don't do something about it there will be a bad STRIKE with Nurses, Clerks, Cleaning Staff, Trades people, and where will ya be to then, when you come in for your BAD COUGH into Emer., or to an Appointment and it is very dirty there or very short staffed that you have to wait in Emer. for 12 hours, or what about to have A surgery and it's cancled for a year.....well guess what it's time for everyone to wake up cause when it all happens in the next couple of months that Eatern Health is on strike it wont be just the Tradesmen workers its going to be maybe the whole staff and team cause They are ALL under payed there!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Dave
    March 15, 2012 - 08:35

    There are many issues facing this Monster we call EasternHealth, right now there are issues with Nursing (New Grads,LPN's,PCA's),the issues with the trades workers are entirely due to wages,I have watched a job posting for a painter/plasterer remain on their site for over a year now top salary $38,844 before taxes per year. In the private sector this type of job would earn twice that salary or more, easy without the BS that comes with working for EasternHealth. There is adaquate money put into EasternHealth to operate it optimally however the money is not used in this way, there is total mismanagement of budgets. Money wasted on bad decisions such as arbitration cases,managers that do not manage,trivial infrastructure issues such as the placement of video cameras to act as managers while keeping the managers on staff. Oh boy there is so much to look at. I hope the new auditor general does an audit on all aspects of easternHealth both acute and long term care sections.

  • Harold
    March 15, 2012 - 08:08

    $43,000 anually with ALL benefits?? come on guys your not doing too bad. lets not get too greedy here. different employers pay different wages, it's your right to move on to a higher paying job if you want.

  • Tom
    March 15, 2012 - 07:05

    Stop the belly aching. If you want private sector wages, then go to the private sector. But remember that there is no job security, random hours, many times working 6-7 days a week, sun up to sun down, so no family life, even if you work in the province. No pension, no medical, and no dental. Or stay where you are too, and work your regular shift, every second weekend off, full pension, medical and dental. Home for supper, lots of time for the family. Your choice, but you can’t have it both ways. No wage increase. Either go after the private sector, or keep your cushy job, with all the benefits and shut it.