Top court asked to review order for new trial in Newfoundland drownings case

NEW TRIAL — In this 2005 file photo, Nelson hart waits for testimony during his first-degree murder trial in Supreme Court in Gander. Mr. Hart was granted an appeal in the conviction of the murder of his twin daughters.

Nelson Hart is pictured in court in this file photo.

Published on October 26, 2012; Published on October 26, 2012
The Canadian Press

Topics :: Supreme Court of Canada , RCMP , Newfoundland , Canada

ST. JOHN’S, N.L. — Prosecutors in Newfoundland have asked Canada’s top court to review an appeal court ruling ordering a new trial for a man sentenced to life in prison after he was convicted of drowning his twin daughters.

Nelson Hart was found guilty in 2007 of first-degree murder in the deaths of his three-year-old daughters on Aug. 4, 2002, at Gander Lake.

Last month, a three-judge panel of the appeals division of provincial Supreme Court unanimously ruled Hart should have been allowed to testify in private at his trial.

The judges cited his “tendency towards epileptic seizures and his difficulty in thinking and speaking clearly under stress” and with lots of people around.

In a split 2-1 decision, the court ruled that a confession Hart gave during an undercover RCMP operation should not have been entered as evidence.

It will likely be weeks or months before the Supreme Court of Canada decides whether it will review the case.

Rate
Top of the page

Comments

Wanda

- October 27, 2012 at 18:09:02

Mental illness or whatever, this father should have come to his senses somewhat when he heard his little daughters screaming. Obviously, they had to be screaming from the instant they hit the water while fighting for their survival. If his illness or seizures were that bad, the three yr. olds should not have been in the car with him in the first place.

Submit a comment

Submit a comment Your name* Email* (we keep all emails private) Write your comment here*
Agreement
We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

Conditions I agree with these conditions.
Winston Adams

- October 26, 2012 at 21:45:29

So much for respect by the crown for the Charter of Rights when the appeal court here clearly sees a miscarriage of justice due to a mental disability and the crown wants to take this to the Supreme Court of Canada. How many with disabilities get locked up without due process. Crockwell has got the ROYAL treatment. Would Margaret Tredeau have been treated like this for some incident from her acknowledged disability? But the common person -- well they're sport.

Submit a comment

Submit a comment Your name* Email* (we keep all emails private) Write your comment here*
Agreement
We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

Conditions I agree with these conditions.
Tax payer

- October 26, 2012 at 21:24:53

Another one who knows how to use the legal system.

Submit a comment

Submit a comment Your name* Email* (we keep all emails private) Write your comment here*
Agreement
We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

Conditions I agree with these conditions.
Peggy

- October 26, 2012 at 20:02:05

Seems these two precious little girls will not receive any justice for their drownings.

Submit a comment

Submit a comment Your name* Email* (we keep all emails private) Write your comment here*
Agreement
We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

Conditions I agree with these conditions.

Submit a comment

Submit a comment Your name* Email* (we keep all emails private) Write your comment here*

Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.