Mayor wants bandstand saved

Bonnie Belec
Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

Vote on Bannerman Park proposal postponed for a week

The Bannerman Park bandstand, which dates back to 1950, may be torn down as one of the options in the redevelopment plan. However, the mayor hopes to keep it intact. — Telegram file photo

Whether their memories are clear or cloudy, everyone who ever hung out around the Bannerman Park bandstand has them, and St. John’s Mayor Dennis O’Keefe is no exception.

Following Monday’s regular council meeting, the mayor said nostalgia, history and culture are some of the reasons why he’d like to see the bandstand saved.

“I look upon the bandstand as being the heart, the symbol of Bannerman Park, much the same as the bungalow is in Bowring Park,” he said regarding the Bannerman Park redevelopment plan (a skating trail and proposed pavilion.)

“It’s the only longstanding structure left in the park dating back to 1950. It is a structure that has many memories for a whole lot of people,” said O’Keefe.

Parks and recreation committee chairman Coun. Frank Galgay was expected to present an option of the proposed plan to council for approval Monday. However, when he stood to make his recommendation, he instead asked for it to be postponed until next week at the request of the mayor.

O’Keefe said it was deferred for a week in order to allow Tract Consulting, the consulting firm involved in the redevelopment and revitalization of Bannerman Park, the time to give the full council a briefing on the options available, including the option of integrating the bandstand in the new concept plan for the park.

“The committee has all of the information, but I think it would be wise for Tract Consulting to meet with the full council, and that will happen next Monday and council will then make a decision. The future of the bandstand is a decision of council. Council has a very good working relationship and partnership with the Bannerman Park Foundation, and we have a Bannerman Park master plan just like we have a Bowring Park master plan. But each of the projects involved in the plan would have to have approval by council, so it’s good for the full council to have a briefing before we actually vote,” said the mayor.

According to the parks and recreation committee’s report to council, it was recommending council approve option No. 1, which is “to demolish and replace the existing bandstand with a larger, more accessible pavilion conducive to various uses which at present cannot be accommodated by the existing structure; that the roof design of the new structure be reflective of the simple roof design of the existing bandstand; that council approve the concept design for the skating trail proposed to surround the new pavilion.”

The other options outlined in the report are —  retain and repair the existing bandstand, adaptive reuse/redesign of the existing bandstand, or retain existing bandstand (as an ornamental piece) and construct a new pavilion.

“Some people have told me their memories are dubious; others have said they’re great. Being a west ender, I have my memories, one in particular of the bandstand, and I’m sure the bandstand touches the hearts of a lot of people in this city. So I see no reason why the option we can select, and it is one of the options, is we have the skating trail which I think is marvellous, we have the pavilion and we also, as part of that process, keep the bandstand and refurbish it to some degree. There’s no reason why we can’t have both,” he said.

The mayor’s particular memory of the Bannerman Park bandstand involves a buddy and two bicycles.

O’Keefe recalled he and his friend rode from their downtown St. John’s homes to the park one day and when they got to the bandstand they decided to ride like the wind around it, in different directions. He said that lasted for about four minutes before the two smashed into each other and they had to hobble home, pushing their bikes.

“So no matter what the memory,” he said, “everyone has one.”

Organizations: Bannerman Park Foundation

Geographic location: Bannerman Park, Bowring Park

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page



Recent comments

  • Anna
    November 20, 2012 - 08:52

    This is so embarrassing, to think of the serious issues, this council could be discussing and they spend time on this. It is time for this council to get its priorities straight and stop wasting time on topics like this one.

  • seanoairborne
    November 14, 2012 - 16:22

    I'm all for progress also,but,to tear the bandstand down is simply ignorant!!I have many fond memories of singing with a bunch of my little friends many years ago in the old bandstand...Kinda street corner bee-bop,and hearing the echo that made us sound like Pavarottis!We'd also go in there to get out of the rain.As for the place smelling like urine,that must be a recent occurrence?We simply went behind a tree or to the (urine-smelling) washrooms to take a whiz!Maybe that's what Jay was referring to?I can't remember "pinky bottles"being strewn all over the place in the bandstand.That sounds like a security issue to me.Not the fault of the bandstand!In conclusion,the bandstand at Bannerman Park should not be torn down.It would be like tearing down the Colonial Building to make way for a modern eyesore just because it's old or because some bum decides to take a whiz behind one of the columns!!That doesn't make any sense to me at all.By all means,build high rises on Water St. despite the protests of the lunatic fringe.But,please,use your heads here and incorporate the old bandstand into something a little more usable.But keep this structure and its historical and nostalgic significance in tact!

  • Eastender
    November 14, 2012 - 09:01

    I don,t agree on to many things that Major O,keefe do but this one I certainly agree on I grew up in the east end downtown I like others spent alot of time playing in this park,I think this band stand should be perseved if they can do it.Yes it do need to be cleaned up and a bit of work needs to be done on it.Like the other parks this is a part of history that should remain.

    • Jay
      November 14, 2012 - 14:25

      Doc's nostalgia seems somewhat misplaced. If he's a westender he should probably be remembering Victoria Park, or maybe Bowering Park. I grew up in the east end and can still remember going to Bannerman Park in the morning and urging at the smell of urine emanating from the bandstand. I also remember the broken pinky bottles left by the local winos keeping you at a safe distance. I can hardly ever remember a band playing there, and the only entertainment that ever came from that place was Art Stoyles playing his accordian. It's an obsolete, poorly designed eyesore. It has absolutely no historical value, and should be torn down. Why don't we replace it with something that has decent acoustics, and if we truly want to bring some honour to the new place, we should name it after Art. He's the only one who ever added any value to it.

  • Doug Smith
    November 14, 2012 - 08:48

    Demolish it as fast as possible. Its as ugly as sin. There is no historical value in it, why keep it ?

    • Chantal
      November 14, 2012 - 09:28

      Agreed, Doug, but it's no more ugly than that broken sewer pipe passing itself off as a fountain.