'A child who was crying out for help'

Glen Whiffen and James McLeod
Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

Youth advocate issues damning report; minister acknowledges system failed boy

There were a lot of questions following the shocking, early morning fire Nov. 17, 2011 in which a 54-year-old man died in a St. John’s boarding house set ablaze by a troubled 16-year-old boy living in the same house.

The boy had ignited his mattress and called 911. No longer with his family, he had been living in the house on Springdale Street for seven months.

Four other men escaped the fire.

When firefighters and police arrived on the scene that morning, the teen was on his knees on the sidewalk, sobbing uncontrollably.

A year later in court, he was sentenced to a three-year youth term. He had pleaded guilty to manslaughter, three counts of arson with disregard to human life, along with single counts of arson causing bodily harm and breaching two youth court orders.

At the time, Judge Colin Flynn called it a harrowing case, “a tragic set of social circumstances, in light of this (teenager), has led to a second set of tragic circumstances, the death of a 54-year-old man.”

The case prompted an investigation by the province’s Advocate for Children and Youth, Carol Chafe.

Tuesday, in St. John’s, Chafe said the investigation identified deficiencies in services being provided to the youth by various government departments and agencies. This included a lack of collaboration and sharing of information, and a lack of documentation and assessments.

The scathing report, entitled “Sixteen,” contains 30 recommendations to improve the system and reduce the risk of another child going through a similar experience.

Forty interviews were conducted, including with the youth, his family members and the professionals involved in his life. Two out-of-province psychiatrists were contracted to provide their expert opinion. An intensive review of policies, procedures and legislation was also carried out.

“This investigation reveals the story of a child who was crying out for help,” Chafe says in the forward to the report.

“Due to deficiencies in the system, there were times when his voice was not heard, his rights were not respected and his right to services was not upheld.”

The youth was born in 1995 and lived with his mother until he was 15, when he was removed from her care by the Department of Child, Youth and Family Services and placed in an alternate living arrangement (ALA). Several weeks later, on his 16th birthday, he signed a youth services agreement (YSA) and moved into a shelter. Following stays at two different shelters, he moved into the bedsitting room on Springdale Street.

Child, Youth and Family Services Minister Paul Davis acknowledged there was a major failure back in 2011.

“They’re a very difficult set of circumstances and a very tragic set of circumstances,” he said.

“There were failures in relation to that young person, and there were gaps. I can tell you, as a department, we have taken many many steps since then to work to close these gaps to provide the best service that we can for children and youth.”

Davis said the department was in transition back in 2011, as a result of services being spun off from the Department of Health and other parts of government into the stand-alone Child, Youth and Family Services Department.

“We are committed to working with the advocate,” Davis said.

“I think it would be pretty difficult to put a time frame on (implementing her recommendations) at this point in time. I think the next big, important step for us is to, once we’ve had a good comprehensive look at the recommendations, is to meet with the advocate and have a good discussion with her.”

Liberal House Leader Andrew Parsons said that isn’t good enough.

He called it a “scathing report, and necessarily so.”

Parsons said action needs to be taken right away.

“It’s really troubling, and I think government needs to answer to this,” he said. “They can’t do this fast enough. There shouldn’t be a delay.

The report’s conclusion states that despite the involvement of professionals from the departments of Child, Youth and Family Services (CYFS),  Justice, Health and Community Services, the RNC and Eastern Health, the youth’s best interests were not put first.

“While (the youth was) an active client of the (CYFS) on paper, he was not of primary concern throughout the program areas he encountered,” the conclusion states. “There was significant evidence of non-adherence to policies and/or best practices by social workers involved.

“Additionally, there was evidence of misinterpretation of (CYFS) policies at the management level. Failure to complete comprehensive assessments, delays in the input of file documentation and delays in file transfer further impeded the continuity of service provision …”

The report noted, “a lack of appropriate housing for youth was evidenced by (his) living conditions after his 16th birthday, which identified a major gap in services for youth in this province who are part of the Youth Services Program.”

The report stated there seemed to be a lack of co-ordinated effort between the multiple agencies dealing with the youth, in part due to poor communications.

“(The youth) was not mature enough, emotionally, nor did he have the coping skills to be placed in what was, for the most part, an unsupervised placement,” the report said.

“Impulsive, intermittently expressing both suicidal and homicidal ideation, increasingly helpless and hopeless, and with a serious substance abuse problem in many respects, (the youth) was set up for failure.”

 

 

Organizations: Youth and Family Services Department, CYFS, Department of Child ALA Department of Health Health and Community Services

Geographic location: Springdale Street

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page

Comments

Comments

Recent comments

  • Political Watcher
    December 04, 2013 - 18:24

    There are two tragedies here: the child who was forgotten and Paul Davis as Minister for children. He couldn't even manage restaurant inspections now he is head over the child protection office. Listening to him try toanswer questions today was sickening. Sure, when he was with the RNC he had all dalto prepare his settlements butnow that he has to think on his feet he is a duck out of water. No wonder this Gov't is sinking faster than a beachrock.

  • This is a Shocking case of Child Neglect brought on by the gutting of the Social System in NL!
    December 04, 2013 - 10:24

    This is a terrible case of child abuse that will not only impact on this young man for the rest of his life and his family, but also the family of man who died in the fire. The past 10 years of governance in Newfoundland and Labrador have seen nothing but the gutting of the social programs in favor of using the resulting monies to develop the people's natural resources so that the already ultra rich can prosper while the electorate of the province will have to exorbitantly pay off the debts. The Muskrat Falls Project has sucked every cent out of the social programs and it will suck every cent out of the hydro consumers and tax payers of Newfoundland and Labrador. Those would-be saviors who orchestrated this mess certainly sucked us into an economic situation that will make us all paupers.

  • This is a Shocking case of Child Neglect brought on by the gutting of the Social System in NL!
    December 04, 2013 - 10:02

    This is a terrible case of child abuse that will not only impact on this young man for the rest of his life and his family, but also the family of man who died in the fire. The past 10 years of governance in Newfoundland and Labrador have seen nothing but the gutting of the social programs in favor of using the resulting monies to develop the people's natural resources so that the already ultra rich can prosper while the electorate of the province will have to exorbitantly pay off the debts. The Muskrat Falls Project has sucked every cent out of the social programs and it will suck every cent out of the hydro consumers and tax payers of Newfoundland and Labrador. Those would-be saviors who orchestrated this mess certainly sucked us into an economic situation that will make us all paupers.

  • This is a Shocking case of Child Neglect brought on by the gutting of the Social System in NL!
    December 04, 2013 - 09:59

    This is a terrible case of child abuse that will not only impact on this young man for the rest of his life and his family, but also the family of man who died in the fire. The past 10 years of governance in Newfoundland and Labrador have seen nothing but the gutting of the social programs in favor of using the resulting monies to develop the people's natural resources so that the already ultra rich can prosper while the electorate of the province will have to exorbitantly pay off the debts. The Muskrat Falls Project has sucked every cent out of the social programs and it will suck every cent out of the hydro consumers and tax payers of Newfoundland and Labrador. Those would-be saviors who orchestrated this mess certainly sucked us into an economic situation that will make us all paupers.

  • original townie
    December 04, 2013 - 08:02

    @ Geri...isn't it time we were responsible for our own actions? Do you not think we should look to the parent (s) and their responsibility in raising children, the environment a child grows up in. Did the parent(s) look for help when he was in their care? A lot of questions here unanswered. Blaming the government, I don't think so.

    • Douglas
      December 04, 2013 - 09:23

      So, if people are responsible for their own actions, why blame the parents? Are you suggesting that there are extenuating circumstances in determining one's behaviour or not? Are you responsible for your own simplistic thinking, or is it the fault of the school system?

    • Darlene
      December 04, 2013 - 09:45

      original townie...its obvious you didn't read the report. Learn to read and then comment please!

    • Darlene
      December 04, 2013 - 09:46

      original townie...its obvious you didn't read the report. Learn to read and then comment please!

    • Darlene
      December 04, 2013 - 09:47

      original townie...its obvious you didn't read the report. Learn to read and then comment please!

    • Geri
      December 04, 2013 - 10:49

      reply to original townie: absolutely...people who are somewhat healthy in their mind usually do take responsibility for their actions. What about those that aren't? who's fault is that? Do you have any idea how many people there are in our society who need help? How many families who are in our social welfare system through no fault of their own but because of a family history of mental illness, abuse, self-abuse and lack of education. I am not making a blanket statement that the government is responsible for 'parenting', but they are responsible for those in their care. Obviously in a situation where mental health is not the issue society expects parents to be responsible enough to raise responsible adults, however, no one is perfect in this area either. Many kids who are raised in so called 'normal' home environments will also commit offenses for which there must be consequences, this is 'teaching' a child and under normal circumstances that child will not repeat the behavious. Sadly this deserved more help that he was given. We are paying good tax dollars to our government to provide these services to those who cannot help themselves, due to mental health issues. Count yourself darn lucky if you have none such these issues in your family, but don't be so quick to judge others.

  • Geri
    December 04, 2013 - 07:08

    The responibility for this terrible, sad, event lies squarely on the shoulders of our government. There is a severe lack of resources in NL to deal with these issues, and there are so..so...many young people and families who are in trouble and need help and guidance from professionals in order to be mentally healthy so they can deal with the basic challenges of life and living. There are many issues and challenges that our government face everyday, however, sufficient resources to deal with physical and mental health should be more of a priority if we want to have less crime, suicides, abuse of women and children, etc.. Most of all we need to focus on helping children as they will be the adults of the future..

    • John Smith
      December 04, 2013 - 08:01

      ....err I think it was this 16 year old who was committing crimes....not the government. Young people can drive when they are 16, have babies, they can make decisions, and they are ultimately responsible...this is not a 4 year old we are talking about here....time for the person responsible to take some responsibility....