Vatican must do more before being forgiven: victim

Barb Sweet
Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

The Catholic church has done nothing to warrant being forgiven, says a sex abuse victim.

Pope Francis. — Associated Press file photo

“What Pope Francis said doesn’t mean a thing,” said the Mount Cashel survivor, who does not want his name used.

“He can bow his head, shuffle, look at the ground as he is walking, but this is nonsense.”

Last week in Vatican City, Pope Francis asked for forgiveness from people who were sexually abused by priests, and vowed that there will be no going back in the church’s fight to protect children.

Francis made the off-the-cuff remarks after coming under criticism from victims’ advocacy groups for a perceived lack of attention to the problem and ongoing demands that he sanction bishops who covered up for pedophiles.

In his remarks to members of the International Catholic Child Bureau, a French Catholic network of organizations that protects children’s rights, Francis said he felt “called to take it upon myself” and “ask forgiveness” for the evil that some priests had committed against children.

“The church is aware of this damage,” he was quoted as saying by Vatican Radio. “We don’t want to take a step back in dealing with this problem and the sanctions that must be imposed. On the contrary, I think we must be even stronger. You don’t play around with the lives of children.”

But forgiving the church is not something the St. John’s senior — who was physically and sexually abused at the former Mount Cashel orphanage as a boy in the late 1940s into the 1950s — can do based on the way he feels the church has reacted to abuse victims’ claims and their anguish.

“We, in Newfoundland and Labrador, the survivors of sexual assault at the hands of the Christian Brothers and Catholic priests, have been in a constant struggle for the past 30 years to have redress. Every obstacle allowable under the law and outside the law have been used to deny our legal rights,” the former Mount Cashel resident said.

The one thing that would  prove atonement, the man said, is for the Vatican to open all church files and archives to the public for scrutiny.

“Then maybe we can see they are really serious,” he said.

The Catholic lay order Christian Brothers last year settled with abuse victims in Canada and the U.S., claims that included Mount Cashel residents.

The Roman Catholic church in St. John’s has said it did not have direct supervision of the Christian Brothers. Civil action regarding abuse at the orphanage, as well as unrelated cases involving Catholic priests, continues against the archdiocese, which has also said in the past it has been working as quickly as it can to address all claims of abuse against it.

The former Mount Cashel resident said he remains hopeful for resolution in the outstanding civil action by victims.

“Every time it comes up, it’s like mud slung at you,” he said.

“It’s like a ceaseless river that runs on.”

Organizations: Christian Brothers, International Catholic Child Bureau

Geographic location: Mount Cashel, Vatican City, Newfoundland and Labrador Canada U.S.

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page



Recent comments

  • SurvivorThriver
    April 16, 2014 - 10:56

    I couldn't agree more. Actions speak louder than words. There's no total healing from being sexually abused by a religious, but we can - with support - move forward. All the best on your healing journey. A fellow Canadian survivor.

  • Michael Kelly
    April 16, 2014 - 07:19

    Perfect and Uncorrupted Divine Law centers on Equity and Fairplay (Eye for an Eye, Tooth for a Tooth), because that is its Purpose. The RCC claims to be the Viceregent of the Christ, which, if True, gives them the Ultimate Authority on Earth to Enforce Divine Law. Pope Francis, nor the RCC Heirarchy, seems to understand this. Restitution to the Victim against the Assets of the Violator for Forgiveness in Order that the Victim may be made Whole again. This is Exactly the Point that the Writer of this article is trying to make. Years of abuse at the Hands of "Evil Brethren and Priests" cannot be just Forgiven and Washed Away. Forgiveness requires Sincere Repentence, a Change of Heart and Restitution for Redemption (Someone has to Pay the Price of Redemption, whether it be the Victim or another as in the Perfect Example of Jesus). Though the RCC will Preach Grace, the Victim has no obligation under Divine Law to grant Grace as in the Case of Civil-Criminal Law where the Violator-Perpetrator looses his-her Life to years of Imprisonment or Worse. In the case of this Article, Pope Francis would be Wise to dissolve the Mount Cashel Orphanage and a portion of the Diocese that had supervision over it, sell off the Assets and place them in a Distribution Trust to be Equitably Distributed by a Trustee Chancery that would Open Up and Try the Claims of the Victims. This Chancery Committee IMHO would best be headed by a Lay Catholic Woman, which would report directly to Pope Francis through a Curia Committee set up in a similar way to collate the Reports of Chancery Committes Worldwide and monthly present a Verbal and Written Report to Pope Francis. \Lastly, IMHO if Pope Francis does not address this Church-Wide and "Evil" Problem in this Way, he is not Competent to Rule with Divine Law and God will Wholly-Holy Bless his Reign's Efforts, which for the Most Part, by themselves, thus far, are Blessed.