Dark side of town

Pam Frampton
Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

“The human race has had long experience and a fine tradition in surviving adversity. But we now face a task for which we have little experience, the task of surviving prosperity.”

— Alan Gregg (1890-1957), scientist

“City enjoying good times,” a headline in The Telegram read this week. In the story, St. John’s Coun. Bruce Tilley talked about signs of prosperity in the metro region with all the fervour of a salesman kicking the tires of a used car.

“Retail trade is up. Personal income is up. We’ve had the largest increase in median family income. … Total employment is gone up by 10,000 jobs over the past three years.”

But, as anyone who has ever bought a used car will tell you, beneath that newly buffed shine and waft of new-car-smell spray, a heap of problems could be lurking — a transmission about to conk out or a botched post-accident repair job.

And the same goes for the city of St. John’s.

I’m not disputing Tilley’s numbers or begrudging him his pride in how well this region is doing economically. But there is more than one side to the coin, as I’m sure he would readily acknowledge.

My husband and I ran into a friend who lives on our street the other day. He was searching fruitlessly on the side of the road for his partner’s jewelry box, stolen when their house was broken into.

We could relate, having been targets ourselves a couple of years ago.

And that’s the trouble — residential and commercial break-ins and thefts are so common now that we hear about it and shrug our shoulders. What can you do?

But make no mistake, your equilibrium is shattered. I still arrive home from work every day with trepidation. Will there be another muddy bootprint on the front door?

What’s behind the break-ins is even more troubling: addiction, often. Oxy, Dilaudid, cocaine, Ecstasy. Name your poison — there’s plenty of it out there.

Desperation, poverty, the growing gap between rich and poor, often lead people to seek escape through drug use.

Addiction leads to crime, and also to danger — both in terms of the health of those addicted and other members of the public who have to worry about their children or pets being pricked with needles discarded in the street.

Addiction also leads to desperation, which might account for the proliferation of massage parlours and prostitutes in our capital city.

The notion of a St. John’s awash in prosperity conjures up images all bright and emphatically colourized like the award-winning provincial tourism commercials — not a piece of trash or a pothole to be seen.

But the true picture has a few more flaws.

Our roads are in rough shape, and many citizens of this city still do not have basic amenities, like sidewalks.

Those of us fortunate enough to have sidewalks often have to forfeit them in winter.

On Water Street, those sidewalks are often populated by a handful of folks down on their luck, panhandling their way through another day of despair.

A further sign of prosperity: garbage. This is one dirty old town. If the amount of thrown-away fast-food containers and cardboard coffee cups on the sides of the road is any indication, plenty of people in this city can afford to eat out.

But there’s plenty of hunger here, too, with the pressure on food banks, school lunch programs and soup kitchens showing no sign of abatement.

And what about homelessness? Tilley says the city went “flat out” in encouraging hotels to be built. We need to bring the same zeal to bear in encouraging affordable housing developments.

First-time homeowners are having to wait longer before they can afford to buy, and there’s a dearth of decent rental housing. Slum landlords and unsupervised boarding houses, on the other hand, are a little easier to find.

This city’s big on cruise ships and conventions, but we need to be as concerned about our citizens as we are visitors.

Cruise ships and conventions are good for the economy, but they come and go, while the rest of us remain here with our sky-high assessments, daily armed robberies and pockets of poverty.

“The quality of life can’t be touched,” Tilley says.

I’d disagree with him there. A survey of Telegram readers last year found that many people feel unsafe in their neighborhood.

The truth is, this city no longer feels as friendly as it once did. There are more knives on the street. More muggings. More smash-and-grabs. More thugs out driving around armed with baseball bats and bear spray, just in case. More drugs. More guns.

By all means, let’s celebrate and laud the successes of this city, but let’s acknowledge the failures as well.

Because we will not have truly achieved prosperity unless it gets equitably spread around.

Pam Frampton is a columnist and

The Telegram’s associate managing editor. She can be reached by email at


Twitter: pam_frampton

Geographic location: Water Street

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page



Recent comments

  • Danny
    May 01, 2013 - 00:06

    A slap on the wrist for the same low life revolving door court docket clients is one of biggest problems.Criminals are not rehabilitated in HQM Penn but only hardened.So many of the same criminals get a couple months in jail only to be back breaching probaton over and over knowing full well not much if anything will be done by the justice system.It is a sad state.Come to Nfld prime time to be a criminal :(

  • crista
    April 29, 2013 - 08:05

    another interesting article Pam, the world of shrugging shoulders and if you give a comment to the articles???? the world of shrugging shoulders????

  • krykos
    April 28, 2013 - 20:53

    Sounds like this is a city among other cities. No better, no worse. The bad and the good. Like the world at large. Why should it be any different? Where there is drugs today there were always lots of drink in the past. This was never a clean living kind of place if I've understood things. Not to say we should not try to improve things for those less well off but let's also rejoice about the improvement for so many people.

  • Anna
    April 28, 2013 - 15:15

    Excellet article. I wonder if th mayor and councillors ever walk around this city for a day. Do they ever speak to the people who voted for them? Can't they see the garbage situation is getting worse and cleaning up George Street is not going to fix it the massive garbage problem we have here. Where are the lines on the streets, it's almost May and nothing has been completed on this yet. Everyone I know is afraid to walk at night by themselves, there is no police presence. I fear because of the huge salaries we are paying for workers in this city, there is no money left for the essentials.

  • Jay
    April 27, 2013 - 14:10

    Pam, Good article, and far more insightful than Tilley's "rah rah vote for me" pitch. Oh, and it doesn't take much for the jealous baymen to come out of hiding does it. Even they don't want to live in the outports.

  • Richard
    April 27, 2013 - 08:47

    Maybe offering townies $250,000 to move to an outport of their choice would solve all these problems.

  • Sam
    April 27, 2013 - 07:36

    Just wondering why you don't publish Trevor Taylor's article online? I have read a couple of his pieces and he has hit the nail on the head. Give us a chance to be able to comment on that too.