Apple TV has limited appeal

Geoff Meeker
Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

I have never owned the Apple TV device until now. It sounded intriguing but frankly, I had no use for it. I'm set up with fibreoptic cable TV - complete with Netflix - so my TV viewing is already rich with content.

Recently, my parents won an Apple TV unit (retail value about $110) as one of the secondary prizes in a dream home lottery. Having no use for it they offered it to me, suspecting I'd be eager to play with it.

They were right.

It's a tiny device that connects to your TV with an HDMI cable and wirelessly to your computer, serving as a portal from computer to TV. You plug in Apple TV, select the HDMI input, connect to your network and off you go.

The device has very little internal storage - movies, TV shows and music are streamed from your computer's iTunes or from the Cloud.

There are a number of apps on Apple TV, which you scroll through using a remote that is both simple and irritating to use.

It's simple because you can navigate easily and intuitively between apps; irritating because you have to scroll one digit at a time through an alpha-numeric screen whenever you input text.

(There is a free app available that enables the iPad keyboard to interface with Apple TV, which would be lovely except I don't own an iPad yet.)

Apple TV has free services - like YouTube, Vimeo, Flickr and a handful of others - and some paid services, though none really turned my crank.

Qello airs only concerts and music documentaries, while CrunchyRoll offers more than 600 Japanese anime series and movies. They cost about $4 per month.

Movie rentals aren't cheap, at $6 for new releases and $5 regular. You can purchase them as well, for anywhere from $12 to $20.

Once you start watching a rental, you have 48 hours to finish it, and all rentals expire after 30 days.

You can also purchase TV series - old and new - by the episode or full season. One episode of the animated series "Futurama" is $2.50, while a full season is $18. On the higher end, an episode of "Game of Thrones" is $4.50, with the full season going for $44.

There's a bit of free content in there, but not much. If you watch a lot of TV, this is an expensive way to do so.

To cut to the chase, the real intent of this product is to get us on iTunes, where Apple would like to see us purchase movies and TV series with the same frequency that we purchase music - and at a premium price.

It's a business model that holds little appeal to those of us who are already connected to cable and pay-per-view TV.

There are some exceptions, of course.

If you have a lot of video content in your iTunes, Apple TV makes total sense, especially if you already own a number of Apple devices. It will allow you to view all that content on your TV, with the user-friendly iTunes interface.

And some people watch very little TV, perhaps just a handful of movies per month.

In such a case, an occasional $5 rental may well be cheaper than cable.

There is one other advantage to iTunes. Purchased programming and active rentals are stored in the iCloud, accessible on your computer, iPad, iPhone, iPod or TV (via Apple TV).

This means you can access your entire library, wherever you are (it's ideal for travelling with a family, but beware those data download costs).

For me, the one redeeming feature on this device is the Netflix app, a video streaming service that I have raved about in a previous column.

Netflix offers unlimited access to hundreds of movies and TV series, all for $8 a month. Compare that to $5 and $6 per movie on iTunes and you'll see why Netflix is such a runaway success.

If you don't already own a videogame console - which can be pricey, starting around $300 - and want to stream Netflix to your television, then Apple TV is a low-cost alternative.

But if you are already set up with cable TV and Netflix, you should give Apple TV a pass.

Geoff Meeker is public relations consultant who has always had a soft spot for technology. He also writes a blog about local media, which is hosted at www.thetelegram.com.

Organizations: Apple, Netflix

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page

Comments

Comments

Recent comments

  • Tom
    July 16, 2013 - 13:34

    You left out probably what is the most compelling aspect of the Apple TV: Airplay, which allows you to play any media off of any Apple device onto your TV set and mirrors any Apple device. I use it constantly. The Airplay feature is even now being used to turn the Apple TV (along with an iphone) into a Wii-like device that uses motion control for games. It's just started but the possibilities are great. I'm not an Apple fanatic, I've never owned an Apple computer, but I have owned several iPhones down the years and I think the Apple TV is just great, and I think Apple has just gotten started with its potential.

  • Jim
    July 15, 2013 - 19:15

    I tend to agree with your assessment as it relates to TV viewing but don't forget those who are deep into the Apple ecosystem. If you add photo streams (I take a picture on my iPhone and it is available on my TV), Airplay (mirror my iPad display) and all my music connected to my home stereo, I think the $99 is a bargain.