Do you want lies with that?

Brian
Brian Jones
Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

It was bizarre this week to witness St. John’s city council enter the ring and start swinging in the fight over the federal government’s temporary foreign workers program.

The program has recently become one of the most controversial and important national issues.

It is far out of the realm of municipal jurisdiction, but that didn’t stop the governors on New Gower Street from getting involved.

City council voted to send a letter to the federal government asking it to end its moratorium on temporary foreign workers in the restaurant industry.

Specifically, Mayor Dennis O’Keefe will write to Immigration Minister Jason Kenney and ask him to find a “more effective solution.”

Undoubtedly, Kenney will appreciate council’s wise counsel.

“Why didn’t I think of that?” he’ll say. “I must redouble my efforts to be more effective.”

It’s more of the bland banality we’ve come to expect from city hall. After all, these are people who for years have resisted the reasonable requests of its citizenry that city streets and sidewalks be cleared of snow in winter. If they can’t comprehend that basic concept, they really should stay away from an issue such as temporary foreign workers.

Bad foundation

A “more effective solution” will not be found, and cannot be found, because the temporary foreign workers program is a repugnant abomination based on lies and propaganda.

At its core, the program is based on the assumption that Canadian workers are lazy. Thus the oft-heard justification that “foreigners are willing to take jobs that Canadians won’t,” or “we can’t find people to fill these positions.”

None of these statements are objective or factual. They are merely value judgments. You could just as easily, and more accurately, say, “foreigners are desperate enough to take lousy jobs that Canadians aren’t,” or “employers can’t find people who will stay in those low-paying positions.”

It is no accident that the main vocal supporters of the temporary foreign workers program are organizations such as the Canadian Federation of Business, Restaurants Canada, the Canadian Manufacturers and Exporters, and such.

It is also no accident that the dramatic rise in temporary foreign workers in Canada — from 100,000 in 2002 to 330,000 in 2013 — concisely corresponds to conservative governments holding office in Ottawa. (The Tories since 2006, and, from 2003-06, Paul Martin, who was a conservative masquerading as a Liberal.)

Industry’s ills

City councillors commonly comment without a clue. Coun. Art Puddister opined that temporary foreign workers should get wages equal to Canadians rather than a lesser amount, and “should be working for the acceptable standard wage.”

Except that … they are. They do. Minimum wage laws apply to temporary foreign workers. The program also requires that they be paid no less than the average wage paid to Canadians working in the same line of work in the same geographic region.

So, what is the rationale, then, for the program? The first clue comes from the current controversy, centred on the restaurant industry.

Hands up, anyone who has ever worked in a restaurant and been ripped off by your boss.

The restaurant business generally, and the fast-food industry specifically, is notorious for ill treatment of employees. Pitiful wages. Unpaid wages. Overtime work without overtime pay. Even worse, work without pay (managers punching out employees’ time-clock cards an hour before the end of their shifts). And so on.

And yet, the accusation gets twisted, and the finger of blame is pointed at allegedly lazy Canadian workers.

The program should be ended immediately. Foreign workers already here should be granted landed immigrant status, on their way to becoming citizens. And we should say, “Welcome to Canada, where we abhor indentured servitude.”

Brian Jones is a desk editor at The Telegram. He can be reached at bjones@thetelegram.com.

Organizations: Canadian Federation of Business, Canadian Manufacturers, The Telegram

Geographic location: New Gower Street, Canada, Ottawa

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page

Comments

Comments

Recent comments

  • Sterling
    May 23, 2014 - 21:39

    Finally a pointed, direct shot at the misgivings of our political system The true problem lies in that employers are looking for the cheapest, most dependent workers, which just happen to be foreigners who know that if they quit they need to jump thru hoops to stay in canada. It is just a form of slavery when it is just is easy to treat your staff right and pay then right. It is shameful that government cares so little about young Newfoundlanders Are you listening newly elected MHA Bennett, oh wait your first order of business was to make sure that government supported TFW's and not Newfoundlanders. 20 percent unemployment, you can find a tonne of workers, just treat them right

  • Sterling
    May 23, 2014 - 21:38

    Finally a pointed, direct shot at the misgivings of our political misgivings. The true problem lies in that employers are looking for the cheapest, most dependent workers, which just happen to be foreigners who know that if they quit they need to jump thru hoops to stay in canada. It is just a form of slavery when it is just is easy to treat your staff right and pay then right. It is shameful that government cares so little about young Newfoundlanders Are you listening newly elected MHA Bennett, oh wait your first order of business was to make sure that government supported TFW's and not Newfoundlanders. 20 percent unemployment, you can find a tonne of workers, just treat them right

  • Virginia Waters
    May 23, 2014 - 19:26

    Well done. Add to that the spectre of NL's Liberal finance critic joining her conservative friends in government to push for re-instatement of the program. All the while proclaiming how proud she was of bringing in her very own cargo of workers to show Newfoundlanders how to flip burgers. In all, 3,000 foreign workers imported into a province with Canada's highest rate of unemployment. There are legitimate cases where highly skilled workers in short supply might be recruited to help Canadian companies. McDonald's should never, ever be on that list. That NL's next 'elected' premier Dwight Ball supported this smack in the face to our 35,000 unemployed is disheartening. The real 'crisis' in this province is a lack of leadership.

  • BIll
    May 23, 2014 - 17:10

    Town Councilers will stand a better chance of getting re-elected , if they worry more about the good citizens of ST. Johns and not TFWS and big business, who don't want to pay a living wage to local people. I Boycott business who have TFWS.

  • Guy Incognito
    May 23, 2014 - 15:02

    Doc is always weighing in on topics that he has no knowledge or authority on. From the declining population to TFWs. What exactly did he teach in school? Everything?? He is such an expert on so many topics he feels the need to share his thoughts. Does Howdy Doody Doc actually think he has any pull in the big pictures? Doc is an embarrassment and needs to be put out to pasture with some of the other fossils at city hall. One bad decision after another.

    • Concerned
      May 24, 2014 - 06:49

      The problem is when primary research is collected for labour market studies, they rely on honest answers from employers not the employees. Therefore the TFW program derived from answers that suit the wallets of employers. This is a fact!