An idea that’s not worth the gamble

Randy Simms
Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

Who decided we needed another debate about a casino? Seriously, I thought this was settled, with all three major political parties stating categorically that casino gambling was not on.

Now the government of the day is prepared to review unsolicited proposals to build one. What a strange development.

Finance Minister Charlene Johnson says she would give the idea consideration if a proposal came along. How can that be? Her government’s policy opposes the introduction of formal gambling structures, but she says they have to be open to possibility.

“We will always be open-minded for a casino or any other kind of business proposal that comes before us,” she said.

Does that mean the monopoly Nalcor has on energy generation in the province could be broken simply by someone submitting a good proposal for wind or solar power?

I think not.

The problem for the government is that they are saying two different things at the same time. Premier-designate Frank Coleman says he is not pushing for a casino but he wouldn’t rule it out, while the government’s official position is not to allow one.

Casino gambling is not a

good idea for Newfoundland and Labrador, and making the business case to justify such an investment is a stretch.

Our population is small; the numbers needed to support this kind of activity are just not here. Casino gambling will exacerbate the gambling problems we already have, and because our tourism numbers are so low, a casino would have to rely on locals for support. In other words, gambling addicts would be needed to keep the doors open.

The end result would be a redistribution of dollars already in the system, with little gain.  

A cost-benefit analysis might prove interesting to review, but I don’t believe the bottom line for the government would change a whole lot.

Why the government has reopened the casino debate is beyond me.

Opportunities to gamble abound in this province, with VLTs in

every drinking establishment and Atlantic Lotto offerings at every corner store.

Profits from gambling activity — which flow to the government — are significant. A lot of bars would go under if the twinkling bells and blinking lights were removed.

And those gambling profits come at a social cost. Frankly, the money we reinvest to address gambling addiction is mere tokenism. We need to do more to help those caught up in the addiction cycle.

I’m not saying we should ban gambling — it’s a form of entertainment that most people can handle. But as with alcohol, some people are prone to addiction and our obligation to help those we hurt by allowing gambling is part of the price of doing business.

In the next few months we are going to be plunged into the midst of a general election.

All of the political parties will pull out their policy books and espouse the need to diversify the local economy. Surely none of them will suggest that casino gambling is one way of achieving that goal.

Frank Coleman says a casino is not something he will pursue.

“It isn’t an issue that would rank at the highest on my priority list,” he has said.

Good for him. It shouldn’t even be being talked about right now.

If we ever have a direct link to

the mainland (think tunnel) and tourism numbers quadruple, while the cost of delivered goods and services drops like a stone, then we can look at other ways of bringing in new money.

But for now, while we languish as we do, all but isolated from the rest of the mainland, such plans would do more harm than good.

It’s time for our political elites to reignite the imaginations of voters and offer bigger dreams of a better world. It’s all too easy to get lost in political minutiae.

A casino? Is that the best we can do?

Randy Simms is a political commentator and broadcaster. He can be reached at

Twitter: @RandyRsimms

Geographic location: Newfoundland and Labrador

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page



Recent comments

  • Straight-Edger NFLD
    June 02, 2014 - 02:30

    "I’m not saying we should ban gambling — it’s a form of entertainment that most people can handle." Is a mortgage a form of entertainment as well? People are gambling as a super high risk investment is a pension Randy - they can't handle it. This is the sad reality. The handling of entertainment by neer-do-wells, well, they or somebody, with money, can handle ANYTHING, can't they?, as evidenced by imports siezed - heroin, meth, LSD, cocaine, and marihuana. "A lot of bars would go under if the twinkling bells and blinking lights were removed." NO Randy, sorry, the ashtray removal NEVER shut down LIQUOR addiction, nor will VLT units removal. But as with alcohol, ALL OF US people are AFFECTED BY addiction, and must support the white collar social assistance that is ALC, AS, at the same time, we MUST support our addicted relatives to keep good-for-nothings-in-good-clothes in jobs that should not exist - end NLC, end ALC - this is the biggest make work program of all.

  • Guy Incognito
    May 31, 2014 - 17:51

    Excellent article Mr. Simms.......

    May 31, 2014 - 14:45

    -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- From: To: Sent: 5/30/2014 1:36:18 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time Subj: Fwd: *****Are you writing about gambling addiction ?? IF YOU WANT TO WRITE ABOUT THIS ADDICTION GET TO ME ARNIE WEXLER 561 249 0922 cell 954 501 5270 New book All Bets Are Off: Losers, Liars, and Recovery from Gambling Addiction === OUT THIS FALL Written by Steve Jacobson AND Arnie Wexler Arnie Wexler's compulsive gambling spiraled out of control . . . now after forty-plus years in recovery he is a nationally known expert on gambling addiction and helps others to "quit the bet." All Bets Are Off chronicles Wexler's life as a gambler that began on the streets of Brooklyn, New York, flipping cards, shooting marbles, and playing pinball machines. At age fourteen he found the racetrack, a bookie to take his bets, and started playing the stock market. His preoccupation with gambling accelerated until a fateful day in 1968 when it all came crashing down. Wexler's gripping narrative leads us through the dungeon of a compulsive gambler's world—chasing the big win and coming up with empty pockets—and how his addiction drove him and his wife, Sheila, to the edge of life. With help, they managed to escape, and together they have devoted themselves to helping others with the problem they know so well ========================== Steve Jacobson was a sports reporter and columnist for Newsday for 44 years beginning in 1960. He was awarded first prize by the Associated Press of New York and Top Five Sports Columnists numerous times by the Associated Press Sports Editors, and has been twice nominated for a Pulitzer Prize, among other accolades. In 2004, he created, conducted interviews for, and helped script the documentary Jackie's Disciples for ESPN Copyright © 2014 Central Recovery Holdings, LLC. All Rights Reserved. CRP and Central Recovery Press are trademarks of Central Recovery Holdings, LLC. 3321 North Buffalo Drive, Suite 275 | Las Vegas, NV 89129 | 702-868-5826 Arnie Wexler WWW.ASWEXLER.COM HELP LINE 888 LAST BET 561 2490922 CELL 954 5015270 Arnie and Sheila Wexler have provided extensive training on Compulsive, Problem and Underage Gambling, to more than 40,000 gaming employees (personnel and executives) and have written Responsible Gaming Programs for major gaming companies. In addition, they have worked with Gaming Boards and Regulators, presented educational workshops nationally and internationally and have provided expert witness testimony. Sheila Wexler is the Executive Director of the Compulsive Gambling Foundation. They also run a national help line (888 LAST BET) and work at Recovery Road, a treatment facility in Palm Beach Gardens, Florida that specializes in the treatment of those suffering with gambling addiction. Product Details All Bets Are Off: Losers, Liars, and Recovery from Gambling Addiction by Arnie Wexler and Steve Jacobson (Nov 11, 2014) $16.95 $12.98 Paperback Available for Pre-order. This item will be released on November 11, 2014.

  • Pierre Neary
    May 31, 2014 - 07:51

    Agreed. The social cost is just to much. Danny Williams had it right on this issue. NL does not need a casino.