Letter shouldn’t have been printed

The Telegram
Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

Collectively the world’s population must have trillions of thoughts every day. Fortunately for all of us only a very small portion of those thoughts are ever spoken or written down.

When they are written, however, especially for publication, there are many checks and balances to ensure that what reaches the reading public is within the bounds of the laws of libel, the laws concerning the dissemination of hate literature, or within the gambit of societal good tastes.

For example when our premier suggests that Newfoundland and Labrador owns Labrador, she is reverting to colonial-style language that went out with the pod-auger and might be seen by many today as harking back to the days of slavery. But it was an unedited thought for which I’m sure she will ever be regretful.   

In a similar vein, I’ve no idea where Shawn Mitchell’s thoughts transmuted into a letter to the Calgary Sun would fall in terms of hate laws and such. I do feel, however, that these thoughts should never have seen the light of day and that the Calgary Sun and the Calgary Sun alone is totally responsible for the publishing of the letter that has drawn so much fire all across Canada but especially here in Newfoundland and Labrador.

The Sun had a choice and in my view it made the wrong choice and furthermore for Randy Simms (“Hey Newfie… Go Home,” The Telegram, Saturday Aug. 3) to suggest that the Sun should have given this individual a podium to spill his venom from is a rather twisted view of what society believes to be the case.

Randy’s thoughts are simplicity itself.

He wrote: “I’m for giving him the podium so people can put him  in his place.”

Wow! Imagine what would happen to our letters pages, our open line shows, and all other sorts of media if we followed Simms’ advice. Randy seems profoundly misguided in this assertion and I can only assume that he was misquoted or misprinted.

It is a tenet of our society today that the less attention that is focused on the rants of bigots, racists and hate literature in general,  the better it is for all concerned because as we all know the major incentive for writing such letters is to garner attention.

Mitchell was/is no different.

For the Sun to publish this letter seems to indicate serious editorial or management problems at that paper.

It is my view that the Calgary Sun should apologize to all Canadians for publishing such rubbish.

And for Sun editor  Jose Rodriguez to suggest how much they really care about Newfoundlanders, etc., is so much condescending drivel that the Sun really should sit him down for a heart to heart.

I would ask him: are we Canadian East Coasters different in any way from West Coasters, or those who live in the heart of the country? The Calgary Sun does, indeed, have a problem and it goes way beyond one person’s bitter thoughts.

All of us have thoughts at one time or another that should never see the light of day and that includes the premier of the province, Randy Simms, Mitchell, and yours truly.

I sincerely hope that with respect to this letter it is not one of those times.

 

Wayne Norman

St. John’s

Organizations: The Sun

Geographic location: Newfoundland and Labrador, Canada, West Coasters

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page

Comments

Comments

Recent comments

  • saelcove
    August 09, 2013 - 09:42

    Grow some skin and get over it

  • david
    August 09, 2013 - 09:12

    Censorship, that's the answer. Wayne Norman seems up to the job. Let him decide what I get to read.

  • Cashin Delaney
    August 08, 2013 - 22:25

    Mainstream media needs to portray the masses as bigoted, so it's content will seem in relative good taste. This is why letters from concerned citizens with legitimate issues are often ignored while the chaff of narrow-mindedness gets printed. Then we react on cue with our own series of chain-letters-to-the-editor perpetuating the attention. We complain about anoynomous trolls while our own media personalities seem to be sleeping under the same bridge. The only difference is that we know their names.

  • Betty
    August 08, 2013 - 18:19

    Wayne are you saying the premiers step on the right's of the Labradorians? If that true, What would you call's the provincial Liberal party did to each and everyone of us on July 5/2013?

  • Laid Back Larry
    August 08, 2013 - 18:16

    It is just plain wrong to censor the letter because you disagree with it. It is plainly not hate propaganda as defined by law but just one person's opinion.