• Print
  • Send to a friend
  • Comment (7)
  •  

Shooting the messenger

Published on May 28, 2012
Published on May 28, 2012
Topics :
UN , Canada , Newfoundland , Libya

“The offspring of riches: pride, vanity, ostentation, arrogance, tyranny…”

 — Mark Twain

I recently heard and read the coverage on hunger in this country. The report centred on findings from the UN special rapporteur for food, Olivier De Schutter.

This is not surprising to many. One need not look to far to quickly become aware of the role food banks are increasingly providing in our society.

Similarly, poverty and all its manifestations are painfully obvious across the country and particularly in some of the “economic hotspots” across the land.

Nevertheless it is still is startling when this state of affairs is highlighted by such a high profile agency like the UN.

De Schutter indicated the problem is getting worse and many Canadians are finding it difficult affording a healthy diet.

He indicated, “we have in this country more than 800,000 households who are considered food insecure. … Multiply that by a factor of two or three and we have millions of Canadians, many of them children, living in this deplorable condition.”

Not surprising, he also pointed out that the top 10 per cent of the country is 10 times more affluent than the bottom 10 per cent.

Newfoundland is not any different, with many people in this province not seeing much benefit from the economic boom.

Food banks have become a major building block in the country’s social safety net. Very disturbing information when one looks at it objectively.

As disturbing as this report was, what is even more appalling is the reaction of the Harper government.

Did they acknowledge that the status quo is not good enough?

Did they provide a response by way of distinct measures they have taken to reduce poverty?

Did they offer any encouragement to the many disadvantaged across the county? Sadly, not in the least!

Instead, they heaped scorn and sarcasm on the messenger. They basically argued De Schutter was wasting his time coming here and being so brazen as to suggest we have a problem.

Jason Kenney went on to suggest that Canada is a developed country and the UN should concentrate its efforts in the underdeveloped areas of the world.

No one would argue that there are many areas of the world where poverty and hunger are far worse.

That being said, it’s of little comfort to a child living in a family with parents working and struggling to pay the heat bill, deal with the rising cost of housing and put food on the table.

Nevertheless, no problem according to Mr. Kenney.

Here we have a government that prides itself on tax cuts, our financial system, big business and wars in Afghanistan, Libya and so on.

It pursues these priorities while being less than forthright with Canadians on how it spends or plans to spend our tax dollars.

Witness the fiasco with the proposed purchase of F-35 military jets and the lowballing of the money spent on the military mission in Libya. They spend money with reckless abandon on chauffeurs and helicopter rides, while poverty does not even receive lip service.

One need not wonder why there seems to be a growing level of discontent and cynicism across the land.

None of this is to suggest that Canada is unique on how it is dealing, or more to the point, not dealing, with the problem.

But rising inequality, like rising sovereign debt, is not sustainable in the long term.

Governments, especially the current government, should take comments like those from Mr. De Schutter a little more seriously instead of offering up the arrogant responses we’ve heard.

Paul Green writes from St. John’s

Comments

  • Username
    Lane
    - May 29, 2012 at 13:31:26

    Even in the most affluent society, there will always be people who are poorly nourished, due to their own poor choices, drug dependency, idolence, or whatever. However, there is healthy food available to every Canadian who needs it and chooses to access it. No one in Canada - and I mean no one - is being allowed to starve to death. On the contrary, our poorest citizens are also our fattest. The UN should focus on addressing real poverty and starvation throughout the world instead of calling for higher taxes and more welfare here in Canada.

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      Jim W.
      - May 29, 2012 at 13:47:19

      Spend a lot of time in first natins communities, do we Lane? Healthy food is not always available or affordable for many Canadians who are not as wonderful as you. What kind is stupid generalizationi is "our poorest citizens are also our fattest?" That doesn't mean they are well nourished. Try living a couple of months on a social assistance income rather than sneering at everyone "beneath" you.

    • Username
      PETER
      - May 29, 2012 at 14:00:40

      Not sure where you get your information Lane, but from my 20+ years experience you are way off base. Only a small minority in the position of being poor are due to poor choices, drugs etc. Healthy food is expensive and there are people who cannot afford it, many people, and the numbers are growing. Our poorest citizens are fattest, in some cases, as all they can afford in the cheapest food. You really should research this more, the growing class is our elderly, on CPP benefits only, I deal with them first hand. They are not on drugs, not lazy or anything else you mention, just poor. Tell me where these people access these healthy foods you talk of, they don't have the funds to buy them, and food banks don't give it out. Food banks and soup kitchens are increasing in numbers of clientelle and again, most of there people are in the position due to the economy and government policies, nothing more. Do more research!

    • Username
      Eli
      - May 30, 2012 at 12:43:36

      Time someone asked why powdered or whole milk is so out of reach. Could the Milk Marketing Board have any influence on it? Huge administrative costs there.

  • Username
    PETER
    - May 28, 2012 at 22:00:06

    Yes, excellent article, this from someone who has volunteered with a food bank for 20 years or more. The clientelle is growing and it's getting harder for food banks to keep up with the demand. At election time I have heard from election to election that they are working on fixing the situation for the needy, yet the demand on the food banks keeps growing. With the rise in food prices, gas, utilities and on and on makes it harder and harder on the working poor, and seniors. With the EIC changes we at food banks must prepare for that increase as well, we do not know how we will keep up. Not only are the marginalized finding it difficult, but so are our main support, the middle class. They too find it harder, and donations are dropping off. Paul Green has it 100% correct, the current government is making it more difficult, they are either blinded to what is happening, or they are just more concerned with their own nests, and with the affluent. It pains me to hear from seniors who have to choose between medication, food or heat. Time to pull out of the Middle East, forget about super war planes, stop tax cuts to big business, time to help the working poor, the disadvantaged, the unemployed, and stop using food banks as a building block and be more concerned for the majority of the population, not just the rich and politically connected.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Jason Green
    - May 28, 2012 at 10:54:05

    Another great article from Paul Green!

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Eli
    - May 28, 2012 at 08:28:12

    Well said. Couldn't have been expressed any better.

    Submit a comment

Submit a comment

Submit a comment (we keep all emails private)
Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.

Advertising

Newsletter

Please enter your email to receive our free newsletter

Subscribe to news alerts
loading...

Tely Twitter

Advertising