• Print
  • Send to a friend
  • Comment (12)
  •  

It’s all about greed

Published on June 8, 2012
Published on June 8, 2012
Topics :
Florida , Arizona

I was watching a story on the news tonight that left a sour taste in my mouth. It was about temporary workers being brought into the province to fill positions that our own people have no interest in filling.

This in itself doesn’t bother me, the fact that we need to bring in foreign workers is great if it’s because there are more good jobs than there are people to fill them.

No, it’s what the employers council of this province says is the reason why they are needed, namely the current EI system.

That is just a self-serving, non-relevant excuse used by these wealthy owners of businesses, such as the fast food industry, to try and influence the government into eroding the EI program even further by making it even more difficult for people, including seasonal workers, to qualify for employment insurance.

Thus, they hope, this will make things more desperate for those local workers that they’ll have to accept the puny wages and part-time hours that this fast food and other industries like them offer.

It really makes me angry when I hear millionaire owners of certain businesses and their well-paid representatives stating they need to bring in cheap labour from other countries because very few locals want to work for part time minimum wages.

They have their own ulterior motives in blaming it on the employment insurance system — but curiously omitted from the news report is how the employment insurance system is responsible for this state of affairs.

If it was explained how the EI system negatively affects their industries, it would reveal their selfish intentions for blaming the employment insurance system.

Stated in the report were examples of businesses such as in the fast food industry, where the only way an employee would be able support a family, pay a mortgage, feed and clothe the kids, afford to pay property tax, sales tax, the tax on the hydro bill (a shameful practice by the government on a basic necessity) is if they either were the owners of such businesses or were the well-paid managers of such (the owner’s representative).

Don’t get me wrong, there is nothing wrong with being wealthy or being a well-paid manager, but there is in being greedy. I believe, actually, the reason they need to bring in foreign workers is because those millionaire business owners refuse to pay wages and offer significant hours of employment that would enable local workers to make a decent living working in these industries.

If the wealthy business owners would leave their estates in Florida or Arizona long enough to come back to their estates in this province and explain that they only require part time employees to run their businesses, then I can accept that. Don’t blame it on the employment insurance system, but lay the blame where it belongs — on their own greed.  

Glenn Collier

St. John’s

Comments

  • Username
    Herb Morrison
    - June 11, 2012 at 22:07:21

    It is very telling to me that despite their their abundance of business saavy, some people are so obviously lacking when it comes to discerning those things which really matter to most people. I refer specifically to both the lack of heart and the lack of sufficient backbone to stand up for what they believe in by identifying themselves. While at the same time displaying levels of both self-absorbtion, and self-righteousness that would force even the strongest of stomachs to turn in disgust.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    This "Business Man" commentator is frightening in what he proposes for himself and his business colleagues. I'm Shivering with fright. Honestly I am.
    - June 11, 2012 at 10:22:19

    A Business Man So in essence you are saying those of us who are at the bottom of the economic and educational strata have no say. Our lot in life is to accept what the Governments in conjunction with the Corporations are willing to give us in wages, with no control from Union, or else go lie down and expire. As we know what you will give us to survive will be far less than what is required. If that is to be the case we, the people, should wrestle control of our natural resource base right at this very moment from our Government leaders. Our Government leaders once they get elected think they have the God Given Right to do as they darn well please, including taking control of our resources for themselves or for their Coroporate friends. We saw it all in the last economies that have gone bust. The heads of Corporation and their top brass of which there were many in some Corporations earned Millions of dollars annually and in some. You "A Business Man" under the economic regime you are calling for will be a very rich man with the people's resources and the rest of us will be like the underdeveloped countries of the World eeking seeds out of the ground to keep from starving to death. Someone PLEASE Reform the Government System in this country, where the politicians and their crony Capitalist Friends have way too much control over our natural resource base, before we, the majority, are reduced to the level of some of the poorest countries in the World that are run by Dictators.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Those responsible for the World's Economic collapse should be sent off to the Gulag.
    - June 10, 2012 at 12:53:57

    We should banish the Government Leaders and the Corporation Heads, who brought down the World's Economy in a wall of dust in 2008, to the Gulag. They are punishing the little folk, their underlings with their exorbitant greed. If Crony Capitalism is what rises from the dust of World Economies falling off the cliff in 2008, soon all the NATURAL RESOURCES of the World will be in the hands of the Government Leaders for the sole benefit of the Corporations and the Government Leaders who enabled it. The Natural Resources of the World belong to the World's people so that they can sustain their families, they do not belong solely to those who manage Governments, and the Corporation Heads who have the influence of the ears of Government Leaders, or in some cases are the Government Leaders themselves!!!!! We want a more honest World. In order to have that we have to fight off today's Corruptors and replace them with Honest individuals who are willing to run our Governments and Corporation with the attributes which should come naturally to a well balanced person. They should know that everyone needs to have the ability to make a living in a World of rising prices, so that can they support their family.

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      a business man
      - June 10, 2012 at 22:17:43

      banish me....go for it. I will just move my company elsewhere. I don't care who my workers are. I have the right as the owner of my company to dictate what wages will be paid, regardless of anyone's ability to make a living. Those with no skills or education find themselves working 2-3 jobs, where as those with an education and in-demand skills seem to be earning more and more and more. Seems just to me. Everyone deserves a living wage, but they must earn it. I will not provide a living wage to anyone without a post-secondary education, and no one can force me to do so.

  • Username
    Ed Power
    - June 10, 2012 at 09:32:10

    Does anyone else find the comments of "Busines Man" and business groups such as the Employers Council to be just a tad hypocritical? These promoters of free enterprise and the godlike ability of the "Market" to regulate itself twist themselves into logical knots as they attempt to hold two conflicting positions at the same time. When jobs are scarce and the numbers of workers available to fill them is large, well then the low wages, long hours, unpaid overtime and lack of benefits are just "the natural forces of the Market's response to the labour situation, - simply supply and demand, don't you know." John Smith's "Unseen Hand" is working just fine. When the situation is reversed, and the number jobs available is high and the workers to fill them is scarce - as rarely as that situation occurs here - well then, the ability of the Market to regulate itself is decidedly ungodly. Jobs are unfilled because "people are lazy", "the EI system is too generous", "Government Regulation is too great", "more Government Regulation is required" (contradictory, I know, but I'm just repeating their own words - they really shouldn't speak where cameras and recorders are present), "the Minimum Wage is too high", "benefits/pensions/vacations/sick leave, etc. ad nauseam, ad absurdum" are all to blame for the inability of Employers to find Employees to fill their vacancies. Apparently, the great and omniscient god "Market" has periodic fits of senility, fits which strangely coincide when the market force pendulum swings in favor of workers and labour. I have a novel idea for our business people and employers. Why not let market forces, you know - Supply and Demand - determine the wages to be paid? After all, it has served you so very well in the past.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Doug Smith
    - June 8, 2012 at 16:58:07

    Glenn, an excellent article. You did a fine job in portraying the truth of the matter. Doug Smith, GFW

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    Which side are you on?
    - June 8, 2012 at 11:37:00

    Glen, you hit the nail on the head. This government (not unlike previous governments) continues to undermine the living standards for the working class. Many of us are complicit: we cheer when a plant closes throwing our brothers and sisters out of work, on the grounds that they were too greedy by expecting a living wage and that they brought it on themselves. We chide them later for getting EI and social assistance and demand that they take any job going regardless of their financial and famial obligations, lest the "taxpayer" have to pony up. But if anyone mentions raising taxes on our wealthy masters, we react in horror. Compassion and solidarity are vaues that threaten those who own the system.

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      a busines man
      - June 8, 2012 at 22:46:20

      they are not MY brothers and sisters. Frankly, I would love to see EI abolished so that any money that I save by paying EI can be given to MY brothers and sisters. And yes, if the government raises the corporate tax rate, I will move my company.

    • Username
      Holden
      - June 9, 2012 at 10:31:46

      For what business you get from me it will just as well that you move NOW!

    • Username
      a business man
      - June 9, 2012 at 17:56:33

      Holden, I will move my company when it suits me best. My company exists for the benefit of myself and my family. I did not start it to provide jobs for workers or to contribute to the tax base. The decisions will consider what is my best interest and nothing else. The reality is you do not have a say when I move my company, neither do my employees. It is my decisions, and I will make it as I see fit. Until I go, I will pay decent wages to Accountants, engineers, scientists, lawyers, and will never pay a penny above the minimum wage for unskilled workers. I will continue to hire workers as individual contractors, and I will continue avoid EI by doing so. I will continue to do everything that I have said, because it is all perfectly legal and consistent with my best interests.

  • Username
    mom
    - June 8, 2012 at 08:28:21

    If you look at rental properties in the paper you will see that people need a decent wage just to keep a roof over their heads these days. If they want to eat as well...

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      a business man
      - June 8, 2012 at 22:52:49

      well, then these people who need a decent wage have to offer the employer that is worth a decent wage. In today's economy, the labour of an unskilled uneducated worker is only worth the minimum wage. That doesn't mean the world is ending. Accountants, engineers, scientists, lawyers, entrepreneurs, teachers, bureaucrats and many many others are earning a decent wage today. Those that are not earning a decent wage are likely the unskilled uneducated people who have nothing to offer except the labour. As a result, they can be easily replaced and are thus not worth paying a decent wage. Why paying a decent wage when someone else will work for less. Why wouldn't the employers pay the cheaper worker and money home and spend it on their own family. I sure would. Yes, people need a roof over their head, but that does not mean they are entitled to a decent wage. To get a decent wage, one must offer the employer value in the form of work production at a competitive rate.

Submit a comment

Submit a comment (we keep all emails private)
Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.

Advertising

Newsletter

Please enter your email to receive our free newsletter

Subscribe to news alerts
loading...

Tely Twitter

Advertising