Mount Cashel changed the police, too

Colin MacLean
Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

By Robert P. Johnston

I write further to the July 20 article, “Picking up the pieces,” written by Barb Sweet.

This article discusses the lingering effects of the abuse suffered by residents at Mount Cashel.

I am writing to address the suggestion made in your paper that similar coverup of criminal activity could occur again.

The effects of the Mount Cashel tragedy have changed this province, on many levels. The survivors, as your story points out, continue to struggle with the aftermath.

Having been a police officer for 33 years, I have seen first-hand that the effects of childhood sexual, physical and emotional abuse can stay with a survivor for years.

However, it is not just the survivors who have been changed by the Mount Cashel tragedy.

The laws governing the Royal Newfoundland Constabulary have changed. The relationship between the office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) and the RNC has changed.

The Royal Newfoundland Constabulary has changed.

Civilian oversight of the RNC exists on numerous levels.

Changes in laws governing the RNC

Amendments to the Royal Newfoundland Constabulary Act, 1992, have formalized a process whereby citizens can air grievances against individual police officers (up to and including my own rank of chief of police) and against the policies and practices of the RNC. The public complaints process set out in the legislation imposes strict time lines and opportunities for civilian oversight through the Office of the Public Complaints Commission.

Changes for the Office of the Director of

Public  Prosecutions

At the time of the Mount Cashel coverup, Constabulary officers routinely sought the direction of the DPP as to whether or not charges should be laid in a wide variety of cases. As a result of the lessons learned from Mount Cashel, this process ceased.

A police officer controls the investigations; the prosecutor controls the prosecution, which does not commence until a charge is laid.

While prosecutors may be consulted by police officers for legal advice, they do not issue directives. The distinctions in the roles are clearly set out in the respective policies of the DPP’s office and the Constabulary.

Changes in the Constabulary

We are constantly training our police officers so that they are better equipped to use new technologies and understand the ever-changing face of the law. Furthermore, we have engaged in a partnership with the Department of Child Youth and Family Services in a training program entitled the Collaborative Approach to the Investigation of Child Sexual Abuse.

We have put great emphasis on encouraging women to choose policing as a career, as we know that a police service that better represents the population, better serves that population. Officers receive training in ethical

decision-making during their training at Memorial University.

Most importantly, and through the lessons learned from both Hughes and the Lamer inquiries, the RNC has had a fundamental change in our approach to investigations. Although we are a paramilitary organization, we actively encourage debate and a contrarian view. On major cases, we assign one officer whose job it is to question the steps taken in the investigation.

Civilian oversight

The Office of the Public Complaints Commissioner has a mandate enshrined in legislation to provide civilian oversight to the actions of the RNC and its officers. Further, the Public Service Commission and the Human Rights Commission can review the conduct of our police officers.

Given these changes, the RNC is subject to extensive checks and balances that significantly reduce the opportunity of a coverup. It is quite simply, a different world than it was 37 years ago.

It is unfortunate that your article did not advise the public of the existence of these safeguards.

Robert P. Johnston is chief of police with the Royal Newfoundland Constabulary.

Organizations: Office of the Public Complaints Commission.Changes for the Office of the Director, Department of Child Youth and Family Services, Office of the Public Complaints Commissioner Public Service Commission Human Rights Commission

Geographic location: Mount Cashel

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page



Recent comments

  • saelcove
    July 30, 2012 - 12:34

    Eli is 100%right police are not as trust worthy as they once were

  • Carol Crocker
    July 29, 2012 - 01:23

    While dealing with my sexual abuse case I had nothing but positive experiences during my interactions with the R.N.C. in both St. John's and Corner Brook. I always found them to be courteous, respectful and helpful during such a trying time. They always put me at ease when I found things to be a little overwhelming at times. It can't be easy dealing with our stories especially the content of our stories. A big Thank You to them!

  • Daniel Corbett
    July 28, 2012 - 21:17

    Dear God man! Have they moved your office from Fort Townshend to the dark side of the moon or some other place that keeps you in perpetual darkness and everlasting ignorance of what is going on in your own jurisdiction? There are any number of cover-ups receiving daily maintenance and sand bagging in your neck of the woods. Give your head a shake, go outside and check out the scene, if you find you are still here on earth and living on the Island you will quickly learn that there is a full battalion, headed by your Justice Minister and his Deputy who work full time to ensure that issues of a criminal nature, that cry out for justice, will never see the light of day. No amount of new legislation or oversight, civilian or otherwise, would improve your dysfunctional justice system, nothing will work when the courage and will to do what is right is absent.

    • Eli
      July 30, 2012 - 10:47

      You hit all the valid buttons Daniel. This latest spokeslady for the RNC can dance around an issue even better than Paul Davis ever did. In the end she says absolutely nothing.

  • Ron Tizzard
    July 28, 2012 - 15:41

    Excellent article Robert. I think the pieces of (grounded) information provided in your column from the police force's perspective was very informative, and should offer (further degrees of ) succor to those affected from the horrid stories still eminating from the ashes of Mount Cashel's demise. I think your best wishes for these now (still variable) adults, are shared by the broader community. These acknowledgements from those representing 'the safe harbours' for these boy-men, still variably affected to this day' should mean a lot. The sentiments afford a safer listening environment for these 'adults-boys' to share...and that is healing. A Robert Frost parody might offer some suggested succor, perhaps, for the more injured 'adult-boys'...coming out of the darkness, as we hear them these many years many, so rightfully angry, and some psychologically unstable). The world is lonely, dark and deep Promises offered, they said they'd keep While I have many, many miles to go, before I can sleep Still more miles to go before I can sleep How many more miles to go berfore I can sleep....?