- November 12, 2012 - 13:05
Calgary having control of it's municipal act is more the exception than the rule. If the St. John's Act has been under review since 1991 then the city has dropped the ball. The norm is for a city to do the review and submit to the province for approval, not for the province to do the review. Obviously the city has dropped the ball here, not the province. I know this as I have been involved with municipal government for close to 30 years here in Newfoundland. I cannot see the province giving the city control of it's act in light of this one fact that it has been 21 years now doing it's review! The city is at fault here, and even Calgary has provincial guidelines, I also have checked into this.
- S Rowsell
- November 09, 2012 - 22:33
Peter, Actually, I have done some research into what other cities in Canada do (Calgary, for e.g.) , and they do indeed have control of their municipal laws. I spoke with officials who provided this information.
- November 09, 2012 - 10:54
Although I agree that the province should move faster on the review of the City of St. John's Act, I do not believe that St. John's or any other municipality should have control over their own act. This would be something new in legislation in general and no city has an act that is outside provincial control. That would mean that a city could pass a law of it's own that supercede provincial legislation, a very dangerous precedent. If the city act has been under review since 1991 then somewhere the city has dropped the ball, it is them that do the review, recommend the changes to the province who then insure that they do not supercede provincial legislation and pass it into law in the house. Something is very wrong if it has been under review since 1991, again somewhere the city dropped the ball. The province is constantly reviewing legislation, making changes and passing it into law and seldom does that take almost 20 years. The province must maintain control and approval, the city must be more diligent in getting the review done first.