Development by lottery

Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

St. John’s city council is at it again.

Its approval of the Marriott Hotel development on Duckworth Street is yet another example of the city contravening its own development rules.

Sadly, I’m not surprised by their decision. The inconsistency this council displays with development applications leaves citizens and developers not knowing the rules of the development game. This is especially applicable when “council discretion” is used within the approval process.

Considering council is in the midst of a consultation process with its citizens on a new municipal plan, I would have thought council would have stuck to its development rules. The meetings I have attended associated with this consultation process have clearly asked council to provide consistency in its planning process.  Concern has also been expressed with the use of council discretion and whether there should be some restrictions placed on this discretion to ensure consistency.

Another troubling concern of the Marriott Hotel approval is that it is site-specific. The next development application in the same area that contravenes the development rules will have to take its chances — just like citizens and developers do — on council’s discretion.

Kind of like a lottery.

Is this the way to plan a city?


Lionel West

St. John’s

Organizations: Marriott Hotel

Geographic location: Duckworth Street

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page



Recent comments

  • W Bagg
    December 19, 2012 - 07:58

    When there is no municipal plan or real planning in St. John's every development ends up having discretion of council. Planning is a joke, look at Stavanger Drive traffic issues, Southland's lack of everything, and the new residential area on Kenmount has no corner store for miles and little recreation, much like Southlands. Not to mention paying for million dollar fences for federal agencies. ..................and the construction crew building sidewalks this morning, yup, the grou nd won't heave and the concrete won't crack over there. They had to clear it with a back hoe before they could even dig up the ground. Why not start the line painting too while your at it! I think the bike lanes in Cowan Heights are faded!