St. John's, NL
Light snow
Light snow  0°C
Feels like -6°C
(view forecast)

  
 Tuesday February 9, 2010 
Help for Haiti
Tely News Alerts
HOME
SUBSCRIBE
COMMENTS
SPECIAL SECTIONS
ARCHIVES
ONLINE STORE
CONTACT US
ABOUT US
TELEGRAM TEAM
Click to view today's Smart Edition
NEWS SECTIONS
News
Sports
Local Sports
National News
Business
Lifestyles
Arts & Entertainment
Columns
Editorial
Letters to the Editor
Births
Obituaries
Provincial Headlines
Financial News
Special Sections
Full Print Edition - Headlines
Celebrity Daily
Interactive Horoscopes
RSS

TOP 10 ARTICLES
Most Viewed  |  Most Discussed

TELY POLL
Should lottery corporations be allowed to offer online gambling?
 
Yes
No
Undecided

| view past polls

Extreme Evolution Contest

Offshore helicopter inquiry

Cougar Flight 491 Tragedy

InMemoriam

Twitter

Facebook

PHOTO & SLIDESHOW GALLERIES
Creepy Crawlies
Creepy Crawlies
JAN.-FEB. 2010 READER PHOTO SLIDESHOW
JAN.-FEB. 2010 READER PHOTO SLIDESHOW
Winter storm hits Battery, Quidi Vidi
Winter storm hits Battery, Quidi Vidi

BLOGS

Heidi Wicks blog

Steve Bartlett Sidetracked

Meeker on Media

Kenn Oliver sports blog

CLASSIFIEDS / JOB ADS
Telegram Classifieds
Merkado.ca Classifieds
Workopolis
brouze.com

COMMUNITY LINKS
TV Listings
Airport Info
Flight Tracker
Movie Listings
Road Conditions & Traffic Cameras
The 2009 Junior Achievement Stock Market Challenge
Tely 10 Road Race
Tely Jr. Golf Tour
Mile One Centre
Access St. John's
Interactive Lottery Guide
Daily Sudoku
Metrobus Public Transit
MUN Seahawks
MLS Real Estate
Rotary Read-A-Long
Creative Book Publishing

CIRCULATION
Subscribe to The Telegram
SmartEdition - what is SmartEdition?
Be A Telegram Carrier

Today's Front Cover

Cuffer Prize rules 2009

EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES
Jobs at the Telegram

CONTESTS

Fantasy Cup Hockey Challenge

LOCAL NEWS Post a comment | View comments (18) | View latest comment |   Local News RSS Feed
Last updated at 8:53 AM on 17/11/09  

St. John's resident Shawn Lewis has been trying to quit smoking for more than 25 years. - Photo by Barb Sweet/The Telegram
St. John's resident Shawn Lewis has been trying to quit smoking for more than 25 years. - Photo by Barb Sweet/The Telegram
'Light' cigarette case going back to court print this article
Health/Justice

BARB SWEET
The Telegram

As a teenager disgusted by his parents' smoking, Shawn Lewis swore he'd never take it up himself.

That's until he developed a crush on a girl while taking a cadet lifeguard course at CFB Greenwood in Nova Scotia.

"I sat down and she asked me if I wanted a cigarette, and I never put a cigarette to my lips before," Lewis said.

"It was disgusting and gross. I excused myself. I went back to the trailer and continued to empty the contents of my stomach. That didn't deter me. The next day I went back, sat down there again and had another cigarette with her, as hard as my body tried to tell me this was wrong."

Became addicted

That was in 1982, and Lewis was hooked on cigarettes by the end of the summer. People he respected smoked - besides his parents, doctors and military officers.

"I told my father that I was smoking over the summer. The only thing he told me is, 'If you want to smoke, you'll have to go to work and buy your own cigarettes.' He didn't really know the health hazards associated with smoking."

In the early 1990s, married to a girl in St. John's he met at a high school dance, and a new father, Lewis decided that based on marketing, light cigarettes would be a healthier choice and took up Player's Light.

A former member of the military, he's quit on and off since, and this week hopes the court will side with struggling smokers like himself in an appeal of a decision on light cigarettes.

The application for certification was filed by Ches Crosbie on behalf of Victor Todd Sparkes - the class action's representative plaintiff - against Imperial Tobacco Canada Ltd., Imperial Tobacco Company Ltd. and the Attorney General of Canada.

Sparkes' lawyers claimed the tobacco companies descriptions of "light" and "mild" as well as other descriptive terms were part of a deliberate misinformation campaign by the tobacco manufacturer to mislead and deceive the public into thinking the use of such products would have less harmful effects than smoking "regular" cigarettes.

But Supreme Court of Newfoundland and Labrador Justice James Adams said in 2008 the plaintiff failed to establish a cause of action under the federal Trade Practices Act. Adams denied the certification on the basis consumer Victor Sparkes did not buy the cigarettes directly from Imperial Tobacco. But the matter is being heard again by the Court of Appeal Wednesday and Thursday.

Crosbie argues people can't buy cigarettes directly from the supplier.

Lewis originally joined the class action because it sounded like his life story.

"We were blindsided. We were misled and taken advantage of. ... At the end of the day, I wanted to quit. I thought the switch to light cigarettes was going to help me take that edge off from smoking regular cigarettes," Lewis said.

"So they had me. I couldn't win."

Lewis has tried everything to quit, from laser therapy to special chewing gum, and has quit for long stretches. He took it up again four months ago after having quit for seven months.

"It seems like this law that was created to protect us is actually providing protection to the wrong people," he said of Adams' decision.

Lewis said cigarette manufacturers are now marketing cigarettes under names like "silver," "smooth," and "white" and those are just as enticing as "light or "ultra-light."

"Whatever colour they want to put to the packaging or however they want to prepare it, none of it's good for you," he said.

"My main goal of this is to just get it out there and to let people know that there is no healthy cigarette."

Lewis is also looking forward to stores being rid of powerwalls - prominent advertising displays used to market cigarettes.

"Just going in those stores is like cutting chocolate off for the rest of your life and ending up at Willy Wonka's Chocolate Factory," he said.

"How can you not be tempted - that's the powerful grip it has on you. It's something I fear and I know I am going to battle for the rest of my life. And hopefully, God willing, I will finally have the strength to lay the cigarettes down for good."

A provincial law to ban powerwalls takes effect Jan. 1. Meanwhile, a lawsuit against tobacco companies announced by this province a decade ago is still active for the Government of Newfoundland and Labrador, but there has been little progress. No statement of claim has been filed nor has the province proclaimed the necessary legislation to join the lawsuit, although it has been passed.

In October, the province of Ontario joined British Columbia and New Brunswick in a lawsuit against a group of tobacco companies.

bsweet@thetelegram.com

17/11/09  


Comments:
This Conversation is Moderated. What is moderation?
(Post a comment)

Steve from NL writes: Why don't you just quit? Personable accountability here. Stop blaming others. You quit before. Why not know?
Posted 17/11/2009 at 9:21 AM | Alert an Editor | Link to comment
ben dover from nl writes: If you are going to blame anyone for the damage that smoking does on society, blame the ones who are making the most money on cigerattes...the Government! we have such a catch 22 system here, our governments make untold amounts of money in taxes received from cigerattes, but yet, spend amazing amounts of money on health care, often the result of the hazards of tobacco use and the cancers that follow. sue the government...
Posted 17/11/2009 at 9:21 AM | Alert an Editor | Link to comment
Nasty Nate™ © 2009 from St Johns, NL writes: We have a problem here. We have government providing free of charge methadone to drug addicts that never paid taxes on the drugs that hooked them, but those that paid taxes to government for tobacco can not obtain the same. Maybe people need to be going to court to force both Government and the tobacco industry to pay for the withdrawal drugs needed to break the habit.

Why do we fund addiction treatment for illegal drug users but not for legal drugs is the real question.
Posted 17/11/2009 at 9:29 AM | Alert an Editor | Link to comment
James from NL writes: With all due resepect, Ben, the cigarette companies make the most money on cigarettes. The government doesn't *make* money; tax money goes back into provicing services for all of us. If the money didn't come from there it would either come from us in the form of higher taxes or fewer services. Cigarettte companies know how and who to lobby and they have the bucks to do it.
Posted 17/11/2009 at 9:49 AM | Alert an Editor | Link to comment
RP from NL writes: Worthy of a soap opera; hope he got the girl in the end. Thank God she didn't introduce him to hamburgers, he'd be suing McDonalds for making him fat.

I thought the military was all about taking responsibility, which part of the lesson did Mr. Lewis miss.
Posted 17/11/2009 at 10:06 AM | Alert an Editor | Link to comment
Stan Darsh from NL writes: My main goal of this is to just get it out there and to let people know that there is no healthy cigarette.

Well. That's good to know. I was under the impression that Jenny Craig had a line of ciggy's getting ready to fly off the shelves.

Of course there are no healthy cigarette's - except for terminal patients who need the stress relief to make their final days somewhat enjoyable - but if you need to be told not to start up - what he called in the beginning of his article - a filthy habit just so you can have something in common with a certain female, then you need to have a shortened lifespan. Next thing he'll be trying to give birth but sueing the doctor for the labour pains.
Posted 17/11/2009 at 10:20 AM | Alert an Editor | Link to comment
CM fom NL from NL writes: COme one- no where in that article has he not taken accountability for the fact he still smokes. He agrees he should quit. He is saying that for younger people ( who are missing logic) see the word LIGHT and will start. He states he knows it is late for him but he wants to stop it for others inthe future....

I hope he can quit for good- and that the lawsuit wins- I could care less if he or the others got $$ but I would like to see the companies be more accountable.
Posted 17/11/2009 at 10:35 AM | Alert an Editor | Link to comment
San To from NL writes: Today, cadet camps are very strict about smoking, after all, it is illegal to smoke underage, and most cadets are underage...remember, the early 80's were different. Nasty Nate makes an interesting comment...we have programs for illegal drug use, but not legal drugs...as soon as I read that, I thought of the uproar made when Eastern Health banned smoking from their properties. I read one comment from a nurse about denying a dying man a smoke, others saying they shouldn't be told what they can or can't do in their own cars. Call cigeretts what they are...a drug. Like it or not people, they are legal drugs. And people get addicted, just like illegal drugs, and they cause health problems, just like illegal drugs. A person makes the choice to try them, knowning they may become addicted. I'm sure there are lots of people who have tried illegal and legal drugs, and didnt' like them, others do, thats a risk they have to take. But, knowing what we know, once a person kicks the habit, as Mr. Lewis had done several times according to the article, that should be it. Just like any drug addict or alcholic, its an everyday struggle. People have such a different view on them because they are legal. But, an addiction is an addiction, no matter what its to......
Posted 17/11/2009 at 10:56 AM | Alert an Editor | Link to comment
Bea Real from NL writes: this is such a farce. there is only one person that can make you quit smoking and that is yourself. blaming it on advertisements and cigarette companies is foolish. this guy is just wasting time tying up the legal system instead of putting in a good hard effort to quit like everyone else.
Posted 17/11/2009 at 11:17 AM | Alert an Editor | Link to comment
Angela Shortall from St.Johns, NL writes: I smoke. I've smoked for over half my life. I'm also only twenty-two. But apparently I have reached a maturity that Shawn Lewis hasn't. I know there is no one to blame for my actions but myself. No one pinned me down and foced me to smoke, nor did anyone force him. Sadly, we have to be held responsible for our actions regardless of how stupid or foolhardy as they may be.
Posted 17/11/2009 at 11:21 AM | Alert an Editor | Link to comment
Mandy from NL writes: To me, it seems ridiculous to sue a tobacco company for putting 'light' on their packaging.
If anyone was smart enough tor ead the side of the cigarette package they might notice that the difference between regular cigarettes and 'light' cigarettes is minimal.
Also, if you ever look at the cigarettes..The liught cigarettes have a ring of tiny holes along the base of the filter on the cigarette which makes the cigarette seem less harsh.
thats it.
Dont sue the cigarette company because you're an idiot.
Posted 17/11/2009 at 12:06 PM | Alert an Editor | Link to comment
harry L from STJOHNS, nl writes: cold turkey is most effective way ,,, chit or get off the pot , i done anybody can
Posted 17/11/2009 at 12:36 PM | Alert an Editor | Link to comment
Judy from Alberta writes: As a Respiratory Educator, I can relate to the Shawns story.
We live in a free democratic society and people choose what they put into their bodies. However society must recogonize the plight of the smoker, it is an addiction as powerful as any drug and it is very difficult to quit. Of every 100 persons who attempt to quit only 25 are successful after one year. Why? Others , including governments are not sympathetic or energetic about supporting the cause, not enough dollars are put into rehabilitation. The tobacco industry made an after tax profit of nearly 15 Billion in 2003 alone . 45000 Canadians die each year from diseases directly related to smoking we need to intervene as tobacco companies target replacement smokers- generally teens !
The aim might be to target teens about the dangers of smoking - provide concrete examples of the more than 4000 chemicals found in the cigarette.
As a society we need to support individuals , forgot about being judgemental- help your neighbour , encourage and support them, and stand behind those who advocate for education and anti smoking lobbying. Change happens because someone takes that first step- help make change for those who suffer from tobacco addiction
Posted 17/11/2009 at 1:26 PM | Alert an Editor | Link to comment
Funky Monkey from NL writes: Actually San....there is no legal age for smoking, anyone can smoke. It is illegal to buy cigarettes under a certain age, but not illegal to smoke them.
Posted 17/11/2009 at 1:31 PM | Alert an Editor | Link to comment
D B from CBS, NL writes: This is pathetic and nothing more than an attempt to get compensated financially .... It's like someone with an addiction to food ... they go to Maccy D's every day and buy 6 big burgers...Every day they gain weight .. more and more weight .. eventually to the point that they can't get out of their own house .. Their cholesterol is out of this world .. Suffering from major heart disease ... So sue MacDonald's for making burgers right?? I don't think so .. Remember the old saying God helps those who help themselves .. Get a grip young man .. You have your life before you .. throw the smokes aways ... change your friends who are smokers if your health concerns are that sincere .. I had to ... Had to make several lifestyle changes ...This is what's wrong with the world today ... It's always someone else's fault ... Time for people to start taking responsibility for their own actions here .
Posted 17/11/2009 at 4:13 PM | Alert an Editor | Link to comment
Kristyn Lewis from NL writes: What my father is trying to say is not that he believes that people under the impression that there is a healthy cigarette, but that there is no healthier choice when choosing which type of cigarettes to smoke.
Also, Angela, no need to be making comments about someone's maturity when you don't even know them personally. He knows that no one pinned him down and shoved it to his mouth, but the cigarette companies lead him on thinking that he was making a BETTER CHOICE when he switched to the light cigarettes for his health than he was making before.
Posted 17/11/2009 at 5:33 PM | Alert an Editor | Link to comment
Ace from St. John's, NL writes: Obviously some of you didn't read this article very closely. He's not outwardly blaming the tobacco company for causing him to smoke. He knows that it's bad for his health, he has always known, and he has made attempts to quit. By joining the class action lawsuit, this man is hoping that, if it is successful, the cigarette companies will not be able to classify certain types of cigarettes as lighter (which some may understand to mean healthier ) than others because it is a form deceptive marketing. Mr. Lewis wants this because he feels that it might help deter young people from taking up the habit if they are presented with only one choice of cigarette.
Also, fyi, cigarettes used to list fixed amounts of each chemical on the side of the box, not an approximate range like they do now. Back when he started smoking, it probably looked like there was a substantial difference in the amount of tobacco or tar that light cigarettes contained versus the amount contained in a standard package of cigarettes. I knew lots of smokers who thought that lights were better for you. they weren't stupid, just misinformed.
Posted 18/11/2009 at 4:18 AM | Alert an Editor | Link to comment
lynda from ontario writes: Hey isn't it in the commercials that making people pay a bit more money they will just quit; and that the reason cigarettes are over $10. Now tell me with all the tax money that the gov't could still afford all these specialists. We will never know cause the tax money goes into general funds, not truly accountable for what the gov't wants to spend the money on. Who knows, maybe they spent that cig tax dollar on helping the Cancer Society promote this issue. Don't tell me this guy could do all this marketing without peoples donations to the Cancer society (and the marketing professionals) in this non government organization. Now tell me how this cures cancer , yet your donations are going toward it.

The reason for this suit isn't about the health or accountability; it's about increasing the gov't coffers again. Using the money in a general fund, so we can never account for where or what the actual money went toward for sure.
Posted 19/11/2009 at 5:55 AM | Alert an Editor | Link to comment
NOTE
The management of this site emphasizes that it is in no way liable for persons, physical or legal, who are hosted here. Moreover, the managers of this site may not be held liable for errors and omissions that may slip into the information displayed in these reader comments. Everyone who submits a comment should read, understand and agree to the Terms of Usage for this section.

Post a comment:
First Name: *
Last Name:
City/Town:
Province: *
Email: *
Use of an invalid email address may result in removal of the comment.
Your email address will not be publicized.
Comments: *
 
I have read and agree to the Terms of Use
Remember me?
 
Check here to receive email updates on contests, promotions, and other important information from The Telegram.
 
 


 
Recent local news:




Past local news :

February 2010 January 2010 December 2009 November 2009 October 2009 September 2009
August 2009 July 2009 June 2009 May 2009 April 2009 March 2009
February 2009 January 2009 December 2008 November 2008 October 2008 September 2008
August 2008 July 2008 June 2008 May 2008 April 2008 March 2008
February 2008 January 2008 December 2007 November 2007 October 2007 September 2007
August 2007 July 2007 June 2007 May 2007 April 2007 March 2007
February 2007

 






Weblocal - Search. Find. Share.

Are you searching for a product, a service or a local company?

Search

The Telegram   Video-on-Demand
Plan for Woolworths property gets warm reception
Plan for Woolworths property gets warm reception
Update on Danny Williams surgery
Update on Danny Williams surgery
Breast cancer decision postponed
Breast cancer decision postponed
view all | submit video
TNM

Road Cams
Foxtrap
Paddyspond
Goobies

Raise a Reader

CanWest Spelling Bee

NIE Program



Canadian Living Recipe of the day
Recipe of the day
Slow Cooker Pulled Pork Tacos
Slow Cooker Pulled Pork Tacos
More >>







The Telegram
A division of Transcontinental Media Inc.
Village Shopping Centre, 430 Topsail Road
Box 86 - St. John's, NL - A1E 4N1
Contents of this website are copyright © The Telegram
e-mail us at telegram@thetelegram.com


Click here to view our privacy policy.

A Transcontinental Media, Local Solutions Group site

This site is part of the Transcontinental Media Network


Daily Newspapers:
Nova Scotia: Amherst Daily News; Cape Breton Post; The News (New Glasgow); Truro Daily News.
Prince Edward Island: Journal Pioneer (Summerside); The Guardian (Charlottetown).
Newfoundland & Labrador:The Telegram (St. John’s); The Western Star (Corner Brook).
Saskatchewan: Moose Jaw Times-Herald; Prince Albert Herald.
Weeklies and Specialty Publications:
Nova Scotia: The Advance; The Hants Journal; The Kings County Register; Kentville Advertiser; The Annapolis County Spectator; The Yarmouth County Vanguard; The Digby County Courier; The Shelburne County Coast Guard; The Citizen; Nova Scotia Business Journal; Burnside News; Farm Focus; Springhill Record; Bedford Sackville Weekly News; Dartmouth Cole Harbour Weekly News; Halifax West Clayton Park Weekly News; Halifax News Net; The Atlantic Construction & Transportation Journal
New Brunswick: Sackville Tribune Post; ENBusiness.
Newfoundland & Labrador:The Charter; The Southern Gazette; The Compass; The Labradorian; The Aurora; The Beacon; The Pilot; The Packet; The Gulf News; The Coaster; The Georgian; The Nor’wester; The Advertiser; The Northern Pen.
Saskatchewan:Southwest Booster; SaskNewsNow; Coronach Triangle News; Grenfell Sun/Broadview Express; Oxbow Herald; Radville/Deep South Star.
Consumer Magazines:
Canadian Living; Elle Canada; Homemakers; More; Good Times; Canadian Gardening; Canadian Home & Country; Style at Home; Western Living; Ottawa at Home; Vancouver Magazine; TV Guide; The Hockey NewsMochasofaOccasions MagazineGolf Ontario StyleGolf EastGroup Travel Planner.
Services:
Weblocal; Merkado