To insurers, the landscape that Brian Jones paints in “Newfoundlanders are the caplin of mankind” is rather glorious. Jones claims that insurance companies can charge whatever they want for auto insurance, whenever they want. I would suggest to Jones, that he please give Insurance Bureau of Canada (IBC) a call to get his facts straight — the numbers are widely available. Much of the data he references is widely available for the industry as a whole in the province. It is also discussed in the transcripts from the public consultations the Board of Commissioners of Public Utilities (PUB) held regarding auto insurance over the last few months, of which Jones apparently only read a portion.
He suggests that insurance companies are getting rich off the backs off the hardworking people of Newfoundland and Labrador (NL). This is pure fantasy. In 2017, auto insurance companies paid out $1.01 for every $1.00 they wrote in premium. That includes paying taxes to the province in addition to paying salaries and commissions for the Newfoundlanders and Labradorians who work for the industry. Yes, this means that it is costing insurers to do business in the province, and it has been this way for years.
To be fair, the industry does not expect Jones or any other insurance customer in the province to care whether they make money or not. In fact, insurers just want to be able to honour their policies within the province and pay their bills with the pool of funds collected in the province – the way insurance is designed to work. That is currently not happening. The simple solution would be for insurers to ask the PUB to approve rates that would put them back in the black.
But that is not going to help drivers’ pocketbooks. That is why the insurance industry is making recommendations to fix the system: control costs and get better care to accident victims quicker.
Another point that Jones brought up – which he sourced from another industry, and not from the auto insurance industry – was that insurers can change anything they want about their policies and rates charged to consumers. In reality, the PUB must approve any rates that auto insurers charge their customers. Full stop. The PUB has the power to reject rates if they are not actuarially justified.
I suggest that a reporter wouldn’t interview a mechanic about nursing issues, nor would they use information from a teacher to formulate a story on the construction industry. So why is misinformation from the sound bites of another industry being used to report on the auto insurance industry?
Let’s set the record straight. Fact: insurers have left NL because they couldn’t make a profit. Fact: according to General Insurance Statistical Agency data, NL insurance companies paid out more in claims and expenses than they brought in in premiums in 2017, and 2016, and 2015. Indeed, this is the case for each and every year between 2010 and 2017. Also fact: if the landscape doesn’t change soon, the insurance companies currently operating in NL will need to make some tough decisions.
Everyone recognizes that NL’s average auto insurance premium is now past $1,100. That’s about 300 hard-earned dollars more than what drivers in the neighbouring Maritime provinces pay. Let’s hope that the PUB issues its report on the hearing process soon, and that there are clear signs toward making auto insurance work better for NL customers in terms of price and returning to health. That is what we should all be focused on.
Vice-President, Atlantic, Insurance Bureau of Canada